2009 sj.com College Football Poll -- FINAL POLL PG 25!!!!!

Sports Journalists Forum – Media, Newsroom & Reporting Talk

Help Support Sports Journalists Forum:

Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 9/28/09 poll Page 11

Mine:
Team Pvs
1. Florida 1
2. Texas 2
3. Alabama 3
4. LSU 5
5. Boise St. 4
6. TCU 6
7. Virginia Tech 7
8. USC 10
9. Ohio St. 8
10. Iowa 11
11. Penn St. 14
12. Cincinnati 12
13. Kansas 13
14. Miami 25
15. Nebraska 17
16. Oregon 21
17. Oklahoma St. 18
18. Ole Miss 19
19. USF 23
20. Oklahoma 9
21. Georgia 16
22. BYU 22
23. Auburn NR
24. Missouri NR
25. Wisconsin NR

Fell out: Houston (pvs 15), UCLA (20), Cal (24).
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 9/28/09 poll Page 11

My poll:

1. Florida LW 1
2. Texas 2
3. Bammy 3
4. LSU 6
5. Va Tech 5
6. Boise St. 4
7. USC 8
8. Cinci 9
9. TCU 11
10. Ohio St. 12
11. Iowa 13
12. Kansas 14
13. Miami 25 (really hard time trying to slot this team)
14. Oklahoma St. 15
15. Oregon 17
16. Penn St. 16
17. Auburn NR
18. Ole Miss 18
19. BYU 19
20. Oklahoma 7
21. Missouri 23
22. Nebraska 24
23. Wisconsin NR
24. South Florida NR
25. Houston 10
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 9/28/09 poll Page 11

MY POLL

Rank Team (Pvs)
1. Florida (1)
2. Texas (2)
3. Alabama (3)
4. Boise State (4)
5. LSU (5)
6. Va. Tech (6)
7. USC (8)
8. Cincinnati (9)
9. TCU (11)
10. Oregon (15)
11. Oklahoma State (13)
12. Ohio State (16)
13. Penn State (17)
14. Kansas (14)
15. Mississippi (18)
16. Georgia Tech (19)
17. Miami (22)
18. Oklahoma (7)
19. BYU (23)
20. Auburn (NR)
21. South Florida (NR)
22. Missouri (NR)
23. Nebraska (24)
24. Wisconsin (NR)
25. Notre Dame (25)
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/09 poll Page 13

Oct. 5, 2009
The 7 Things I like about you – and 18 I don’t

3422432227_722fdf1227.jpg
3 People Like this. Most don’t.

Slappy4428 has joined the app 25 Things.
31 minutes agoCommentLike

Slappy’s 25 Things about the College Football Poll
Monday, Oct. 5, 2009 at 3:20pm

1. I’m not understanding why Auburn is so low. It’s taken the Tigers five games to score one point less than it did all last season.
2. Are we penalizing Notre Dame because we’re A) sick of Jimmy Clausen and B) hate Charlie Weis? If USC won three games in the last minute, would it have 11 points in the poll or be top 5?
3. Same idea, different result: Did Michigan get booted out of the poll for losing in overtime in a game they were predestined to lose because of DickRod? Would it have happened to Kansas?
4. Iowa’s lucky, but if Michigan wins, will the Hawkeyes freefall?
5. So you know, Central Michigan’s votes are coming from one person, not a group of people who think the Chippies need a spot here.
6. If Boise and Cinci run the table and the rest of the FBS has a loss, should they play for a championship?
7. Is Stanford worthy of a spot?
8. Does Bama get burned at Mississippi or is Jevon Snead the most overrated SEC quarterback since Tee Martin?
9. The last time Webby’s boys cracked the top 25, they peaked at No. 2. Can USF go that high again?
10. Oregon is No. 14 and hasn’t lost a game since they lost a player. Think Chip Kelly has any regrets?
11. Which team gets the bigger patsy this week: Penn State with Eastern Illinois, Texas with Colorado or Boise State against Bye?
12. Nebraska and Missouri on Thursday night? Have these two programs sunk that low?
13. Deep down, think Les Miles likes Nick Saban?
14. Anyone else waiting for Ohio State to be the team to pop Fraud’s balloon this week?
15. My feet resemble bear paws.
16. OK, they really don’t, but I saw that line on one of these once and thought it was ballsy stupid.
17. Which team gets their bubble burst twice and still goes to a BCS bowl – Virginia Tech, USC or Florida?
18. 13 teams are unbeaten – four in the SEC alone. How many remain standing at the end of the weekend?
19. Do four unbeaten SEC teams mean the league is really good or scheduling is really easy?
20. Think if Jim Delany had to do it all over again, we’d have no Big Ten Network?
21. Think if they had to do it all over again, we’d have an 18-team WAC with divisions instead of two nine-team leagues?
22. Biggest disappointment this season? Georgia? Okie State? Oklahoma?
23. Stealing from Whitlock: Which team will win first – Ball State or Kansas City? I say Ball State; KC doesn’t get to play Eastern Michigan.
24. The dome of the US Capital weighs 8,909,200 pounds of cast iron. (just seeing if you’re all still with me)
25. Tebow or Bayou? Discuss.



SportsJournalists.com COLLEGE FOOTBALL POLL
10/05/2009
RK. TEAM (1st) PTS Last

1. Florida (31) 870 1
2. Texas 829 2
3. Alabama (4) 816 3
4. LSU 749 4
5. Boise State 694 5
6. Virginia Tech 663 6
6 (tie). USC 663 8
8. Ohio State 594 9
9. Cincinnati 578 11
10. Texas Christian 554 14
11. Miami (Fla.) 418 23
12. Iowa 399 14
13. Oklahoma St. 397 13
14. Oregon 392 18
15. Penn State 346 17
16. Kansas 325 15
17. BYU 289 19
18. Mississippi 244 21
19. Nebraska 239 20
20. Auburn 232 NR
21. Oklahoma 226 7
22. South Florida 182 NR
23. Georgia Tech 156 25
24 Missouri 113 NR
25 Wisconsin 97 NR

Also receiving votes: Georgia 81, Utah 44, Stanford 41, South Carolina 33, Houston 24, West Virginia 17, Central Michigan 13, Notre Dame 11, Pitt 8, Cal 3, Michigan State 3, Michigan 1

The SportsJournalists.com college football poll committee: Slappy4428 (chairman), 2muchcoffeeman, Agate Page, Azom, BYH, Della9250, Diabeetus, Dparker85, Elliotte Friedman, GB-Hack, Hammer Pants, Hank Scorpio, Huggy, Ishouldcoco, Jesus Muscatel, Joe Schmoe, KYsportswriter, Layman, Madhavok, Matt1735, Orville Redenbacher, Oz, Piotr Rasputin, Popedirkbenedict, Precious Roy, Red Smith Clone, Rockbottom, Rumpleforeskin, , spnited, Starman, Stormsurge, Sxysptswrtr, Trooper Bari, WS, Songbird. Not Voting: Bubbler.
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

okie state's loss to houston is 58 times worse! how can they be 13?

michigan got a single point? seems surprising.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

when notre dame beats usc (not saying it will this year, but in general), i'll show them some more love. irish still a ways away from thinking they're all that.
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

RedSmithClone said:
I'm also shocked that Notre Dame isn't getting much love.

When Notre Dame is looking better-than-mediocre against mediocre opposition, then we can talk about the Irish getting some votes.
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

slappy4428 said:
5. So you know, Central Michigan’s votes are coming from one person, not a group of people who think the Chippies need a spot here.

And just for the record, those CMU votes are not from me, me being the MAC fan boy of the group.

They beat that vaunted Eastern Michigan team on Saturday though and they may make an entrance into the poll.
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

For weeks, I've had this feeling that Alabama -- not Florida -- was the best team in the country. Today, after watching both on CBS, I'm finally going to act on it. If I believe 'Bama would win today head-to-head at a neutral site, then I probably ought to rank them as such.

I know it seems like odd timing given how the Gators just handed LSU a rare prime-time loss in Death Valley, but I just like the Crimson Tide.

1. Alabama
2. Florida
3. Texas
4. Virginia Tech
5. Boise State
6. Texas Christian
7. Iowa (up 5)
8. Southern California
9. Ohio State
10. Miami, Fla.
11. Cincinnati
12. Louisiana State (down eight)
13. Nebraska
14. Oregon
15. Kansas
16. South Florida
17. Penn State
18. Brigham Young
19. Georgia Tech
20. Oklahoma State (down 4)
21. Utah (replacing No. 18 Ole Miss)
22. Oklahoma
23. Auburn
24. West Virginia
25. Houston (replacing No. 22 Wisconsin)
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

1. Florida (0)
2. Alabama (0)
3. Texas (0)
4. Cincinnati (0)
5. Boise State (+1)
6. Kansas (+2)
7. South Florida (+2)
8. TCU (+2)
9. Iowa (+4)
10. LSU (-5)
11. Virginia Tech (+3)
12. Nebraska (+3)
13. Oregon (+3)
14. Penn State (NR)
15. Southern Cal (+2)
16. Ohio State (+2)
17. Miami (Fla.) (+2)
18. BYU (+2)
19. South Carolina (+3)
20. Missouri (-9)
21. Wisconsin (-9)
22. Houston (+1)
23. Georgia Tech (NR)
24. Oklahoma State (0)
25. Oklahoma (0)

Dropped out: Auburn, Stanford.
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

And we'rrrre back ... from Florida. I couldn't vote last week because I was on the sunny beaches of the Keys on an anniversary trip with Mrs. Bubbler. Here goes ...

1. Texas
2. Florida
3. Alabama
4. Boise State
5. Virginia Tech
6. TCU
7. USC
8. Ohio State
9. Cincinnati
10. Oklahoma
11. Iowa
12. Kansas
13. Oklahoma State
14. Oregon
15. South Florida
16. LSU
17. BYU
18. Utah
19. Miami
20. Nebraska
21. Houston
22. Georgia Tech
23. Auburn
24. South Carolina
25. Wisconsin

Last out: West Virginia

I dropped Penn State. Look at their resume, it is absolutely hideous. Compare them to other one-loss teams and there's no way they belong in the poll. The one time they were tested, they got dropped at home by Iowa. Buh-bye Nittany Lions.

I also dumped Ole Miss, which appears to be one of those hindsight are 20/20 overrated teams going into a season. Same for UGa.

I kept Wisconsin because their loss is a higher quality loss than Penn State's, or West Virginia's, or Rutgers, or Pitt, etc.
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

Bubbler said:
And we'rrrre back ... from Florida. I couldn't vote last week because I was on the sunny beaches of the Keys on an anniversary trip with Mrs. Bubbler. Here goes ...

1. Texas
2. Florida
3. Alabama
4. Boise State
5. Virginia Tech
6. TCU
7. USC
8. Ohio State
9. Cincinnati
10. Oklahoma
11. Iowa
12. Kansas
13. Oklahoma State
14. Oregon
15. South Florida
16. LSU
17. BYU
18. Utah
19. Miami
20. Nebraska
21. Houston
22. Georgia Tech
23. Auburn
24. South Carolina
25. Wisconsin

Last out: West Virginia

I dropped Penn State. Look at their resume, it is absolutely hideous. Compare them to other one-loss teams and there's no way they belong in the poll. The one time they were tested, they got dropped at home by Iowa. Buh-bye Nittany Lions.

I also dumped Ole Miss, which appears to be one of those hindsight are 20/20 overrated teams going into a season. Same for UGa.

I kept Wisconsin because I'm an unabashed fanboi without any objectivity, even when they get drilled.
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

I see what you did there, Slappy. :-*

Wisconsin's loss was to Ohio State on the road. It's not like the Buckeyes drummed them out of the Horseshoe, Wisconsin was in that game for quite a while.

Of the one-loss teams I put behind Wisconsin: Penn State lost at home to Iowa, Pitt lost to Duke-losing NC State, Rutgers to Cincinnati at home, Notre Dame to Michigan, Missouri to Nebraska at home, Tulsa at Oklahoma, Idaho at Washington. None of them have a win that is better than any one Wisconsin win, in fact, nearly all of them have wins over far inferior teams to Wisconsin. ****, Idaho might have the best win resume out of all of them.

And all of their losses are worse, save perhaps Rutgers, though the Scarlet Knights were badly beaten on their home field. Wisconsin lost in Columbus.

West Virginia has an argument over Wisconsin, but a weak and unconvincing one. They lost at Auburn. Wisconsin and WestByGod each pounded on bull**** I-AA competition (West Virginia over Liberty, Wisconsin over Wofford).

But when you compare West Virginia's Division I wins (East Carolina, Colorado, at Syracuse, combined record: 6-11) to Wisconsin's (Northern Illinois, Fresno State, Michigan State, at Minnesota, combined record: 12-10), the Badgers have the edge. Plus, a loss at Ohio State is slightly less damaging than a loss at Auburn.

In other words, my rationale is based on logic, whether you agree with that logic or not is up to you, but cram the fanboi BS! :D
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

Bubbler said:
I see what you did there, Slappy. :-*

Wisconsin's loss was to Ohio State on the road. It's not like the Buckeyes drummed them out of the Horseshoe, Wisconsin was in that game for quite a while.

Of the one-loss teams I put behind Wisconsin: Penn State lost at home to Iowa, Pitt lost to Duke-losing NC State, Rutgers to Cincinnati at home, Notre Dame to Michigan, Missouri to Nebraska at home, Tulsa at Oklahoma, Idaho at Washington. None of them have a win that is better than any one Wisconsin win, in fact, nearly all of them have wins over far inferior teams to Wisconsin. ****, Idaho might have the best win resume out of all of them.

And all of their losses are worse, blah, blah, blah....

In other words, my rationale is based on my fanboi BS! :D
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

You're just mad because Ball State will get its first win over Eastern Michigan!
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

Posting my ballot for the first time all year.
As a first-time voter, I wanted the season to shake out a little before posting.

1. Florida
2. Texas
3. Alabama
4. Virginia Tech
5. Ohio State
6. Boise State
7. USC
8. LSU
9. Oregon
10. Oklahoma State
11. Cincinnati
12. Kansas
13. Miami
14. Oklahoma
15. Iowa
16. Penn State
17. TCU
18. Georgia Tech
19. BYU
20. South Florida
21. West Virginia
22. Nebraska
23. South Carolina
24. Ole Miss
25. Central Michigan

GOING OUT
20. Missouri
21. Auburn
23. Wisconsin
25. Georgia

EYE ON
Houston
Utah
Notre Dame
Pitt
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

Had the biggest problem with spot 25.... A lot of it was deck chairs on the Titanic...
Team Pvs
1. Florida 1
2. Texas 2
3. Alabama 3
4. Virginia Tech 7
5. Boise St. 5
6. USC 8
7. Ohio St. 9
8. Iowa 10
9. TCU 6
10. LSU 4
11. Miami 14
12. Penn St. 11
13. Cincinnati 12
14. Nebraska 15
15. Kansas 13
16. Oregon 16
17. Oklahoma St. 17
18. South Florida 19
19. Oklahoma 20
20. BYU 22
21. Utah NR
22. Ole Miss 18
23. Georgia Tech NR
24. South Carolina NR
25. Wisconsin 25

Fell out: Georgia (pvs 21), Auburn (23), Missouri (24).
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

Bubbler said:
You're just mad because Ball State will get its first win over Eastern Michigan!
ME? You have that confused with Hank Scorpio... Now if it was Western, which beat Toledo, which beat Colorado, which hasn't really beaten anyone, I'd be mildly upset
 
Re: 2009 SportsJournalists.com College Football Poll -- 10/5/2009 Page 13

1. Florida (Pvs: 1)
2. Texas (2)
3. Alabama (3)
4. Virginia Tech (5)
5. Southern Cal (6)
6. Boise St. (7)
7. Ohio St. ( 8 )
8. BYU (10)
9. Cincinnati (11)
10. TCU (9)
11. LSU (4)
12. Miami (20)
13. Iowa (22)
14. Oklahoma St. (12)
15. Georgia Tech (13)
16. Kansas (14)
17. Utah (15)
18. Oklahoma (16)
19. Penn St. (19)
20. South Florida (24)
21. Oregon (25)
22. South Carolina (UNR)
23. Nebraska (UNR)
24. Houston (UNR)
25. Notre Dame (UNR)

South Carolina, Nebraska, Houston and Notre Dame replace Georgia, Ole Miss, Missouri and Auburn.

Did a whole lot of shaking things up. Jumped Miami and Iowa into the top 15 and dropped other teams behind them that, looking back, I had ranked too high.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top