Running CFB Playoff Debate Thread

[User 11148]

I’m having a hard time keeping track of my perspicacity on multiple “College Football Week X” threads, so I thought I’d create this one for all CFB playoff-related discussions. Hope you enjoy ... and you better have Clemson in your final four.

 

[LongTimeListener]

Three-loss Clemson?

 

[User 11148]

Three-loss Clemson?

They could survive two ... the committee would forgive losses to Syracuse and South Carolina.

 

[tapintoamerica]

If you're the Big XII, do you care who wins the rest of the way as long as Saturday's TCU-OU winner keeps on rolling? Or does the name brand thing play into your fears, prompting a silent prayer for the Sooners?

 

[LongTimeListener]

If you're the Big XII, do you care who wins the rest of the way as long as Saturday's TCU-OU winner keeps on rolling? Or does the name brand thing play into your fears, prompting a silent prayer for the Sooners?

I don’t think it’s name brand. I think the reason OU would have a leg up on other conference champions is that they won at Ohio State. TCU doesn’t look too good in non-con comparison to, say, Clemson.

 

[tapintoamerica]

I don’t think it’s name brand. I think the reason OU would have a leg up on other conference champions is that they won at Ohio State. TCU doesn’t look too good in non-con comparison to, say, Clemson.

True. That win in the Horseshoe is one of the big ones nationally. Biggest probably Ga winning at ND.

 

[User 11148]

Big 12 seems to be in a bit of a pickle. Whoever wins Saturday will, in all likelihood, have to win again in the championship rematch. Otherwise no Big 12 playoff spot.

 

[tapintoamerica]

Big 12 seems to be in a bit of a pickle. Whoever wins Saturday will, in all likelihood, have to win again in the championship rematch. Otherwise no Big 12 playoff spot.

Yep. Elimination game.
At this point, the conference would love to expel Iowa State.

 

[tapintoamerica]

The creation of the playoff and the difference between qualification and exclusion means, to most Power 5 schools, a difference of $400,000 per school. That's relatively small in a budget of tens of millions annually, but it's cash you can use to make debt-service payments on facilities, for example. Hard not to think of that cash as something you depend on.

And that's why the conspiracy theories will go into overdrive in cases in which a no-chance-for-playoff team upends the playoff-bound favorite and costs everybody -- including itself -- $400,000.

Didn't take long for the NC State coach to drop a few hints after his team lost to Clemson the other day.

 

[Donny in his element]

They could survive two ... the committee would forgive losses to Syracuse and South Carolina.

Too soon. /crossthread

 

[Shropshire Slasher]

Any rankings set forth by the CFP committee before the final one is complete and utter bull**** and a waste of bandwidth and newsprint.

 

[DanOregon]

I've always felt it would be better if they put out a 10 team "watch list" in alphabetical order like the awards committees do. The CFP jams themselves up by putting them in order making the inevitable last week switcheroo look (ESPN)-spired.

 

[Neutral Corner]

As usual, I'm rooting for maximum chaos.

 

[DanOregon]

I'd love it if the CFP expanded to six. All conference champs plus an at-large with two byes. The bottom four play at the 3 and 4 home sites the week after the championship games. Then the final four at new years, with one caveat. Either cut the season to 11 games with a minimum of eight conference games. Or 12 and a minimum of nine conference games.

 

[Cosmo]

I'd love it if the CFP expanded to six. All conference champs plus an at-large with two byes. The bottom four play at the 3 and 4 home sites the week after the championship games. Then the final four at new years, with one caveat. Either cut the season to 11 games with a minimum of eight conference games. Or 12 and a minimum of nine conference games.

Rather it go to the full eight: 5 P5 champs, the best G5 champ, two at-larges.

 

[TyWebb]

As usual, I'm rooting for maximum chaos.

For the first time ever (coughUGAfancough), I'm rooting for a nice, relaxing November.

 

[Michael_ Gee]

I'm glad this thread exists, but it's really more of a playoff speculation thread for now. We need more data to have genuine debates.

 

[TyWebb]

Yeah, we should all just sit quietly until Dec. 3.

 

[Michael_ Gee]

Yeah, we should all just sit quietly until Dec. 3.

I didn't say there was anything wrong with speculation. Done lots of it myself. But we should see it for what it is, a series of hypotheticals.

 

[LongTimeListener]

See ya later, Pac-12.