Saban, other than the national championship season, was very good but not great at LSU.
2000 was an up-and-down rebuilding season.
In 2001, he went 10-3 and won the SEC -- after about a hundred things broke exactly right to enable them to win the West. There were a half-dozen games in November that had to go a certain way for LSU to have a shot, and they all did.
In 2002, the team tanked after Matt Mauck got hurt against Florida (finished 3-2 with two ugly losses and two miracle finishes that evened out).
2003 was the good times.
2004 was good but got screwed up by a total offensive no-show against Auburn.
Saban's LSU teams were always in the hunt, yet also had brainfarts at certain times -- especially on defense, which he's supposedly the guru at. See the 2002 Arkansas game and the infamous Capital One Bowl in 2004.
I haven't seen those kinds of screw-ups from Meyer's teams. I'd put Meyer over Saban any day of the week.