Restaurant stories, advise, complaints and compliments

heyabbott · Feb 12, 2012

At dinner last night, the check comes and as I glance at it I notice that the bottle of wine I ordered is not on the check. So I tell the wife that its not on the bill and I call over the waiter and tell him. It's a $100 check without the wine and its a $27 bottle of wine.

The waiter is thankful that I said something. He would probably have to make good to the owner.
I could haver just paid the cash on the check and left.

He comes back quickly, the only time last night he was quick about anything, with the new check with the wine on it.
I thought he should have comped a dessert or the coffee or something.

Honesty is its own reward, but ...

too much of an expectation?

jr/shotglass · Feb 12, 2012

Probably not too much of an expectation, but if you make quality demands of strangers, you're going to be disappointed more often than not.

There are many -- too many -- people on this earth who just don't think in those terms. Doesn't even cross their minds.

TheSportsPredictor · Feb 12, 2012

Guy is probably just relieved (and shocked). Probably didn't even think of offering a free dessert for that reason.

Care Bear · Feb 12, 2012

Plus, you oftentimes have to get a manager's approval to comp anything these days, and a lot of managers probably wouldn't give approval in that particular situation. And the server may not have wanted to mention his screwup.

But, yes, I would have been a little disappointed, too, in your situation.

BurnsWhenIPee · Feb 12, 2012

Care Bear said:
Plus, you oftentimes have to get a manager's approval to comp anything these days, and a lot of managers probably wouldn't give approval in that particular situation. And the server may not have wanted to mention his screw up.

But, yes, I would have been a little disappointed, too, in your situation.

If I was the server, the last thing in the world I would have wanted to do is point out to the manager my screwup and asked to give you guys something free.

It would have been nice to get something free, but you did the right thing. That should be enough.