Just watched the HBO documentary last night. I am blown away. I didn't know anything about this case until now, and I'm usually a fairly voracious defender of the accused in general.
There is no way in hell that those three kids did it. No way. None of it adds up, and it is completely antithetical to what common sense now tells us about motive and so forth. I recall the "devil worship" hysteria in the 1990s, and a lot of the same kind of stuff was used in the Willingham case.
Echols and Baldwin are more articulate than I am. Just normal, educated guys. Misskelley is, well, "mildly retarded," as they said in the film. It's almost shocking to see the three men today and imagine that the former two hung out with him. It just doesn't fit. But that's teen-agers for you.
Echols spent the last 18 years on death row. That's chilling. Hell, even if he had actually done it when he was 16, and turned into the man I watched in that documentary last night, I can't think of any way to justify putting him to death.