Mike Carey Expert Analysis

[lantaur]

FWIW, was once told by an ex-player turned broadcaster that Carey was all about getting his face on TV.

 

[RecoveringJournalist]

FWIW, was once told by an ex-player turned broadcaster that Carey was all about getting his face on TV.

Then he should have gotten more training before accepting a TV job. Being on TV is not easy, even though a lot of people think it is because there are a lot of really stupid people who are good at it.

Pereira is as polished as they get. Is he always right? Of course not, but he offers good insight.

Carey has no confidence being on TV and it shows. He can get better though.

 

[qtlaw]

The referees are given so much notoriety because they are the guys on camera giving the final call but they are the vast majority of the time just relaying the information from the others who made the call.

Every time I've watched him, his timing has been awful; whereas Pereira has been smooth; its probably more production than Carey but he gets the blame.

I would love to see Cashen get this type of gig.

 

[da man]

The referees are given so much notoriety because they are the guys on camera giving the final call but they are the vast majority of the time just relaying the information from the others who made the call.

Every time I've watched him, his timing has been awful; whereas Pereira has been smooth; its probably more production than Carey but he gets the blame.

I would love to see Cashen get this type of gig.

Red's probably a little long in the tooth to be getting a job like this. I think he's in his 80s.

 

[poindexter]

Cashion was born in 1931. Lets get some people who aren't mumbling into their pudding in 2014.

 

[Boom_70]

I bet there was a lot of back and forth between the CBS and NFL Network suits
today on Carey.

I would start by not having him render a decision until the one on field is announced.
Carey can then be used to provide rule interpretation on decision.

 

[da man]

There is nothing wrong with Carey saying what he thinks and then after the official call is made saying he believes the ref got it wrong. As I recall, he disagreed with a defensive holding non-call, too.

I'm OK with both of those.

 

[DanOregon]

Carey was a great ref, but I'd argue CBS isn't setting him up well at all.

 

[bigpern23]

I bet there was a lot of back and forth between the CBS and NFL Network suits
today on Carey.

I would start by not having him render a decision until the one on field is announced.
Carey can then be used to provide rule interpretation on decision.

I often watch the NFL without the sound these days as I have a large family that is usually around on Sundays, so I acknowledge that I may be wrong on this - but doesn't FOX primarily use Pereira to interpret calls that have been made, giving viewers analysis on the rulebook and calls that have been made, rather than predicting what the refs should call?

I feel like I remember Pereira once saying on Francesa's show that his job is not to second-guess the officials, but rather to give the viewer clarity on why calls are made the way they are and, occasionally, to correct them if there is a misinterpretation or blown call (which obviously come after a call is made).

 

[old_tony]

In the case of most replay challenges, they go to commercial anyway, so the need for a Mike Carey is pretty limited if you ask me. The ruling is announced pretty quickly after they come back from commercial. That's what made Carey's gaffe to funny on Thursday. He had to hurry to say it was a fumble, and it was just a second later that it was ruled down by contact. He had time to look at it during the commercial, but he didn't have time to really show what he was seeing when they got back from the break.

 

[Starman]

All these guys are wastes of airspace -- their function is to lick the nuts of the officiating crew and reassure us every call is right in the end. Just ****ing PR bootlickers.

 

[da man]

All these guys are wastes of airspace -- their function is to lick the nuts of the officiating crew and reassure us every call is right in the end. Just ****ing PR bootlickers.

Except, as noted, Carey disagreed with at least two of the calls he was asked to comment on in that game alone.

 

[Evil ... Thy name is Orville Redenbacher!!]

Carey is pretty bad, maybe they could trade him to The View for Rosie O'Donnell?

 

[exmediahack]

All these guys are wastes of airspace -- their function is to lick the nuts of the officiating crew and reassure us every call is right in the end. Just ****ing PR bootlickers.

I'm feeling this way more and more. I'll watch any game with Al Michaels at the call but, damn, I'm sick of the "Sam Rosen Game" or the "Ian Eagle Game" littering my Sundays.

The only reason I don't turn the sound off on the NFL games that I don't have a major interest in is so that, when something big happens, I can look back at the screen from whatever else I'm doing.

 

[Chef2]

Carey is pretty bad, maybe they could trade him to The View for Rosie O'Donnell?

You might need to throw in someone to the view.

 

[Boom_70]

Example of how Fox uses Pereira wisely

Mike Pereira ‏@MikePereira 2m2 minutes ago

Repeating what I said on-air, holding should have been called on Trufant during the 2-pt conversion. It was within a yard of the LOS

 

[Boom_70]

Carey just never sounds convinced on what he is saying. What a waste of time. On the other hand
MikePereira always adds to the process for Fox

 

[LongTimeListener]

If Carey had been on the Dez Bryant catch, he would have gotten it wrong and it would have been a raging inferno of a controversy.

 

[Boom_70]

If Carey had been on the Dez Bryant catch, he would have gotten it wrong and it would have been a raging inferno of a controversy.

Or CBS would have not brought him on until definitive decision was made by replay officials

 

[Michael_ Gee]

Does Fox even have second and third crews after Buck and Aikman? I swear the guy with Lynch last night was new (I'm sure he wasn't, just anonymous wallpaper) How will they ever do the Open?