Rough Mix said:
It's important to keep in mind while doing this that what you think you know to be true may not be. My grandparents were immigrants and changed names several times. Dates of birth and death, places they were born, dates of marriages all may be different from what you may have been told. I wanted to trace my side back for my kids, so I just kept at it. Eventually I was able to put enough pieces of the puzzle together so I could cross reference everything and it fell into place.
A follow-up to that: sometimes they weren't the ones changing the name or birthdate. If you're relying on census data or info from Ellis Island, the surname could be spelled however the person writing it down thought it should be. Same with date/place of birth. I know without a doubt where one of my great-great grandfathers lived (less than two miles from where I'm typing this right now), and exactly where to find him in the census. But if I'm to believe the three consecutive listings from 1860-1880, he was born in three different states -- including "Rodilan," which we finally figured to be a phonetic misspelling of Rhode Island, instead of some obscure foreign country -- and three different years. Just something to keep in mind. If you think you've found the right person, but something is off by a letter or two (or a year or two), don't automatically dismiss that record. Like Rough Mix says, keep at it.
And sometimes, those "mistakes" are intentional, like the family member who discovered that his parents' marriage certificate was filed a year later than he'd been told ... and approximately two weeks after he was born.
Bob Crotchet said:
Well, this thread is timely: I need to find information on my great-grandmother, who supposedly was a member of the Choctaw tribe, but I've never done any genealogical research. I'd be happy to pay for someone to do this, if 1) it wasn't outrageously expensive and 2) I could be sure of a reliable researcher. Or I'd do it myself if the odds were with my finding it. So, how does one find a good genealogy researcher? Or figure the odds on finding it oneself? ... And my local library does indeed have an ancestry.com subscription.
For something that specific, cyndislist is a good start. You might also try http://usgenweb.org/, a nationwide network of researchers committed to keeping this information free. (Yeah, if any of y'all ever need a lookup in McKean or Potter counties in Pa., give me a ring.) And checking out the
Oklahoma GenWeb site brings me to
Choctaw Nation. Lot of info there.
You know how to research and report a story, right? This isn't any different. If you currently live in the same area that you'd be researching, compile as much info as you can before consulting a professional. (Most charge by the hour once you get past their base rate.) Start with your parents and get every date and place you can think of, work your way back through each preceding generation, and you may well find everything you need without going out of pocket. On the other hand, if you're on the other side of the country, then get what you can and find somebody local to take it from there.
Good luck, and happy hunting.