According to the report Auburn police filed with court papers, at about 3 p.m. members of Compton's party complained to the course marshal that Shampine's party was moving too slow, angering Shampine's brother, Greg, who allegedly turned around and began yelling at Compton's party for being too loud and threatened to "kick their ass" if they didn't shut up.
According to the police report, the parties began to jaw at each other, provoking a shoving match between Compton and Greg Shampine, with two of Compton's party surrounding Greg Shampine during the shoving. To protect his brother, Nicholas Shampine later told police, he charged Compton at this point with his golf club and swung it at him, hitting him above the eyes with great force, knocking him down. Members of Compton's party told police that even as Compton lay on the ground, Shampine threatened to kill all of them and their families if they messed with him.
Officers found Compton sitting on the 14th green, bleeding profusely from the head and vomiting as a friend applied direct pressure with a blood-soaked bandage. Officers observed that the lower third of the club's shaft was bent, indicating it had been swung with great force.
According to the police report, Nicholas allegedly told them, "You are probably going to arrest me, I'm the one that hit him with the club, I don't have any weapons on me."
Ironically, Nicholas Shampine also told police golf party actually had been waiting for the party in front of them.