Deeper_Background
Active Member
- Joined
- Nov 29, 2004
- Messages
- 4,234
novelist_wannabe said:OK, at the risk of left-wing ridicule, explain this: The oceans are rising because of meltoff from polar ice, right? How does this take into account the scientific fact that frozen water takes up more volume than non-frozen water? You put a full bottle of water in the freezer overnight, and the expanding ice ruptures the bottle. The freeze and thaw cycle that causes landslides and falling rocks in the mountains happen because frozen water is larger than non-frozen water. So if the polar ice melted, wouldn't the sea levels go down?
Mystery Meat said:I'm almost POSITIVE it's a photoshop job. Though I'll say this, if the beer looter from New Orleans is shown stealing a polar bear for real, then SI gets a lifetime subscription from this cat.
novelist_wannabe said:OK, at the risk of left-wing ridicule, explain this: The oceans are rising because of meltoff from polar ice, right? How does this take into account the scientific fact that frozen water takes up more volume than non-frozen water? You put a full bottle of water in the freezer overnight, and the expanding ice ruptures the bottle. The freeze and thaw cycle that causes landslides and falling rocks in the mountains happen because frozen water is larger than non-frozen water. So if the polar ice melted, wouldn't the sea levels go down?
e4 said:novelist_wannabe said:OK, at the risk of left-wing ridicule, explain this: The oceans are rising because of meltoff from polar ice, right? How does this take into account the scientific fact that frozen water takes up more volume than non-frozen water? You put a full bottle of water in the freezer overnight, and the expanding ice ruptures the bottle. The freeze and thaw cycle that causes landslides and falling rocks in the mountains happen because frozen water is larger than non-frozen water. So if the polar ice melted, wouldn't the sea levels go down?
i can't tell if you're joking... if you're not, the simplified answer is that ice caps and glaciers don't exist on a singular plane, i.e., they consume space out of the oceans (there's your expansion), and when they melt, the water goes back into the oceans, thus creating the rise in sea level