MLB's Next Commissioner

Sports Journalists Forum – Media, Newsroom & Reporting Talk

Help Support Sports Journalists Forum:

DanOregon said:
Selig really won't get any style points for his tenure - and you can probably argue underlings like Manfred have more to do with success of his tenure than anything, but the game IS in better shape now than it was at the start of his term. Of course, the start of his term was the owner-initiated strike, the loss of a World Series, and then you had the steroid explosion that MLB relied on to win fans back, some really silly new rules, the All-Star Game debacle....he was hardly an innocent in the depths MLB reached.

I think Billy Beane has more to do with the strong resurgence of baseball than Selig.

I do wonder if Manfred is going to do one of those moves that new commissioners often do - like reinstating Pete Rose.

Pete Rose never gets reinstated. Ever.
 
Starman said:
DanOregon said:
Selig really won't get any style points for his tenure - and you can probably argue underlings like Manfred have more to do with success of his tenure than anything, but the game IS in better shape now than it was at the start of his term. Of course, the start of his term was the owner-initiated strike, the loss of a World Series, and then you had the steroid explosion that MLB relied on to win fans back, some really silly new rules, the All-Star Game debacle....he was hardly an innocent in the depths MLB reached.

I think Billy Beane has more to do with the strong resurgence of baseball than Selig.

I do wonder if Manfred is going to do one of those moves that new commissioners often do - like reinstating Pete Rose.

Pete Rose never gets reinstated. Ever.

He will after he dies. Unless Pete Rose is the Highlander. Lifetime bans aren't forever.
 
Football_Bat said:
Starman said:
DanOregon said:
Selig really won't get any style points for his tenure - and you can probably argue underlings like Manfred have more to do with success of his tenure than anything, but the game IS in better shape now than it was at the start of his term. Of course, the start of his term was the owner-initiated strike, the loss of a World Series, and then you had the steroid explosion that MLB relied on to win fans back, some really silly new rules, the All-Star Game debacle....he was hardly an innocent in the depths MLB reached.

I think Billy Beane has more to do with the strong resurgence of baseball than Selig.

I do wonder if Manfred is going to do one of those moves that new commissioners often do - like reinstating Pete Rose.

Pete Rose never gets reinstated. Ever.

He will after he dies. Unless Pete Rose is the Highlander. Lifetime bans aren't forever.

Shoeless Joe has been dead since '51. Last game was 94 years ago. Yet, he's still banned.
 
Pete Rose should NEVER be reinstated. The rule is in every clubhouse and it's clear. You bet on baseball, you are banned for life. And that's the way it should be.
 
How soon after Manfred takes over as commissioner does Bud Selig get picked for HOF induction?

Next available ballot?

Three years?

Five years?

Never?
 
WCIBN said:
How soon after Manfred takes over as commissioner does Bud Selig get picked for HOF induction?

Next available ballot?

Three years?

Five years?

Never?

Next summer. Bowie Kuhn is in, no reason Selig shouldn't be.
 
Starman said:
WCIBN said:
How soon after Manfred takes over as commissioner does Bud Selig get picked for HOF induction?

Next available ballot?

Three years?

Five years?

Never?

Next summer. Bowie Kuhn is in, no reason Selig shouldn't be.

It will be three years.

The Golden Era ballot is for 2015. The Pre-Integration ballot is for 2016. The Expansion Era ballot is for 2017.

Considering his age (he'd be approaching 83 if form holds), if they wanted to fudge and get him in on the Golden Era ballot they could say he entered baseball in the window of the ballot (up to 1972).

I could also see them doing that because there isn't a slam dunk holdover from the last Golden ballot -- Jim Kaat was five votes shy, Gil Hodges and Minnie Minoso were six and Tony Oliva was seven short.
 
Selig was a minority owner of the Milwaukee Braves back in the late 1950s.
 
This guy seems like the driest piece of toast around.
This is what's in demand in the job market, members and moderators.
 
Kepner sniffed around that sentiment the other day. Said Manfred underwhelmed when he spoke, possibly out of deference to the final 5 months of Selig's reign, and that he could have said something exciting -- at least touted the small-market teams (Brewers, Royals, A's, etc) who happen to lead their divisions etc etc.

"I really don’t want to get too deeply today into agendas."

Really, Mr. Commissioner? How about a little deeply then?

Dry toast, indeed.

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/08/15/sports/baseball/mlbs-new-commissioner-watches-a-chance-fly-by.html?_r=0
 
3_Octave_Fart said:
This guy seems like the driest piece of toast around.
This is what's in demand in the job market, members and moderators.

Of course. The only really colorful commissioners they've ever had were Landis and Giamatti.
 
Big fan of Landis.

Apart from banning notable players, he set a double standard when he ordered John McGraw to sell all gambling interests, though he did not order McGraw to sever ties with disreputable high-rollers like Arnold Rothstein. This incites the debate that Landis was able to be swayed by the nature of bias. Later, when Ty Cobb, Tris Speaker, Joe Wood, and Dutch Leonard (by his accusation) were alleged to have fixed a game, Landis exonerated the trio on the grounds that they had simply conspired to bet and not maliciously corrupt the game's integrity. Their innocence, however likely, would probably not have stood with Landis had the charge been made during his first days as Commissioner in the midst of the Black Sox scandal. The event allegedly occurred in 1919, the same year of the crooked World Series. Buck Weaver did not survive the association with gambling, and it is doubtful that the implicated trio would have either.

We'll never know if he would have in fact allowed Babe Ruth to barnstorm because Ruth, always playing his own game, decided to call Landis twelve hours before he departed. An angry Landis, knowing that his title granted him the power to reside over all things baseball, set further precedent as Commissioner when he struck down on baseball games (the Ruth tour) outside of Major League Baseball. At the same time

His contradictory actions in 1921 also impacted the game when he allowed John McGraw secure Irish Muesel after denying him Heinie Groh in a trade under similar circumstances. From there on, owners realized that profitable transactions also required Landis' favor. It was only a question of finding him in a good mood.
 
Starman said:
3_Octave_Fart said:
This guy seems like the driest piece of toast around.
This is what's in demand in the job market, members and moderators.

Of course. The only really colorful commissioners they've ever had were Landis and Giamatti.
At least Bud had some business pedigree.
This guy is a garden-variety Ivy League lawyer.
We've seen with the president that is not indicative of leadership competency.
 
3_Octave_Fart said:
Starman said:
3_Octave_Fart said:
This guy seems like the driest piece of toast around.
This is what's in demand in the job market, members and moderators.

Of course. The only really colorful commissioners they've ever had were Landis and Giamatti.
At least Bud had some business pedigree.
This guy is a garden-variety Ivy League lawyer.
We've seen with the president that is not indicative of leadership competency.
If only the asshole baseball owners would have made George W Bush baseball commissioner after Faye Vincent instead of Bud Selig ...
 
3_Octave_Fart said:
Abbott, do you think the president is a joke?
No joke. Bush the Younger was a failed tragedy, he was never a hero and never was heroic, though he did lack self awareness. He was hubris personified.

Obama is an enigma, almost too self aware, but no joke. The contradiction with Obama is that he seems to lack an aggressive streak and ambition to succeed except for the fact that he was aggressive and ambitious enough to become President. Once that was accomplished, he seemed to lack the drive to act only react.
 
I think the guy shoots straight and wanted to hear his opinion.
Thank you, Abbott.
Back to the bustling conversation about the new commissioner.
 
Manfredi has a bit of Gary Bettman quality to him. Erstwhile
assistant but can't really carry a room.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top