American Idol -- Final 4

[estreetfan75]

Melinda went first. OK.

Blake is second, TERRIBLE beat-boxing and screaching his way through 'you should be dancing'

 

[Dyno]

Eek -- who knew Bee Gees songs were so hard to sing well?

 

[Dignan]

They're 0-for-3 so far.

Blake was awful and LaKisha was worse.

 

[spup1122]

LaKisha was horrendous. Melinda was OK, but I didn't really enjoy it like I usually do.

Jordin is doing OK, but what is with her dress over the jeans???

 

[estreetfan75]

round 1 rankings

Jordin
Melinda
LaKisha
Blake

 

[spup1122]

I'd switch Blake and Lakisha, but agreed.

 

[Dignan]

I'd switch Blake and Lakisha, but agreed.

What you said.

 

[Dyno]

I think Beatbox Boy is going home tomorrow night.

 

[Dignan]

Pretty weak night overall.

 

[Kritter47]

Jordin's second song was flat for about 80 percent of it. And the old-fashioned comment is right on. That song's way too old for her.

Her first song, however, was awesome and probably the best of the night.

 

[BYH]

Man I love Jordin. She's underage so feel free to throw me in the pokey. She's a knockout.

I think she locked it up tonight. She was by far the best. And that dress...wowza.

 

[estreetfan75]

Beatbox Boy will be packing his bags tomorrow night. I'll guess LaKisha will be in the bottom two.

If it's Jordin-Melinda in the finale, Melinda is probably better at this point, but I think Jordin will win the popular vote and is more marketable.

 

[Perry White]

At the moment I can't see Jordin losing.

 

[GimpyScribe]

I know this won't come across as PC as I would like it, but I have a feeling that Blake is going to get through another week.
My reasoning? Jordin, Melinda and Lakisha are going to be splitting the "black diva" vote, while young white america will focus on Blake. He goes home next week, for certain, though.

 

[User 1019]

Meh. It was a weak week. Blake probably gets the boot.

 

[Write-brained]

Wow. Jordin's really grown on me in the last few weeks ... her second best song was better than anyone else's best song. Takisha and Melinda have good voices but no personality. Blake is just too strange.

I guess that Takisha goes home this week because I also think she and Melinda will split the diva vote but then Blake's bye-bye after that.

When's Abba week?

 

[Bob Cook]

I love it when AI assigns someone to sing 30-to-40-year-old songs, and then Simon complains how it's "too old." Then stop making them sing ****ing Barry Gibb songs!

Though perhaps Simon had heard the Dirtbombs' kick-ass cover of "I Started a Joke," and was disappointed no one could match it.

 

[dooley_womack1]

dialidol.com has blake safely in second, and melinda and Lakisha in trouble.

 

[BYH]

dialidol.com has blake safely in second, and melinda and Lakisha in trouble.

Or so your kids told you, right?

 

[ADifferentOkie]

dialidol.com has blake safely in second, and melinda and Lakisha in trouble.

Of course, that doesn't factor in text messages, which you would think would skew toward the younger crowd. Thus you would expect even more votes for Blake and Jordin.
As long as LaKisha isn't in the final, I won't complain.