I thought this episode was just ok, although I loved the previous week's episode, and thought it was hilarious when Ted punched Barney in the junk. Even when this show isn't super funny, I still appreciate the different storytelling, and it's just far more creative than any sitcom out there.
By the way, a few weeks ago I made the mistake of googling sportsjournalist.com to see what the world was saying about us, and I made the mistake of dropping in on Analway, where content matters, and Crazyperson was commenting on one of the HIMYM threads, and mocking one of my comments about Barney and Robin's hookup, so I just want to say:
Hi psycho! Enjoy the echoing rants in your Fortress of Crazytude!