When April Fools jokes go wrong

Sports Journalists Forum – Media, Newsroom & Reporting Talk

Help Support Sports Journalists Forum:

Deskhack

Member
Joined
May 5, 2003
Messages
274
So, the local minor league baseball team (short-season Class A, Padres affiliate), the Eugene Emeralds, send out a press release last night saying that Jeremiah Masoli, disgraced Oregon quarterback, has signed to pitch for them this summer, at about 10:45 p.m. Turns out, though, that it's a joke perpetrated by the team. The local TV stations breathlessly report the hoax, leading their local newscasts with it, and the next day, everyone figures out that it's a joke.

The interesting thing about this? Apparently the TV stations called the PR flack who sent this out, and she confirmed the story. That's what gets me about this, the TV stations did their job as journalists and still got screwed over.

Did the team maybe go a little too far here? And should the flack maybe think about finding another line of work?
 
The whole April Fools thing is getting pretty old. It's funny to play on your friends, but has been overplayed as big public stints since Sidd Finch. Newspapers doing it all over their web sites today was just annoying.
 
public stunts, not stints... i type all day. what the hell am i still doing on a computer??
 
I thought it was funny. And the Emeralds came clean pretty early in the day. It was wrong of the PR people to confirm it as news. All in all, though, I thought it was a good prank.
 
This is just stupid. I'm not advocating great journos to leave for PR, but THIS is why the best journos make the best PR people... they understand that YOU DO NOT DO THIS UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES!!!! Even if it's just a stupid joke. Someday, someone important (not you idiot PR lady) is going to lie about something important, media is going to report it, and stuff is giong to hit the fan... not trying to blow it out of proportion, but that lady's reaction gave me NO reason to think she wouldn't do this again with a "bigger story" in the future at her next PR gig...

Watching the grin (on the video) on that j-school reject's face made me sick. Really bad form. Have Manute Bol sign to play a hockey game. That's a minor league PR stunt. Making a joke, and perpetuating a BLATANT LIE (not to mention using Masoli's name...i know he isn't necessarily the most liked guy, deservedly so, but still...) is ridiculous. Again, grand scheme: not a big deal, but the principle REALLY does mean something here...
 
My first weekly paper would do April Fool's joke stories each year for a few years. We'd have some localized story on some outrageous thing, then at the end of the story, we'd reveal it was an April Fool's joke.

My editor one year got the town attorney to cooperate for a joke story on him landing a guest starring role as a lawyer on a TV show. I got the local star high school wrestler to cooperate on (you guessed it), a fake signing with the WWF. It was all in fun, although we'd always get some complaint call each year. The publisher finally put a halt to it after about five years.
 
I can think of no easier way to **** away the one thing we should cling most stubbornly to, our credibility, than to engage in such piffle.

There's sh*t you're supposed to get out of your system at the college newspaper: Using all the fonts, color headlines, April Fools jokes.

P.S., The PR person shoulda been fired for not letting the TV station in on the "joke" when asked directly.
 
God, I ****ing HATE April Fool's Day. We spend all day calling on stories to confirm that they're real, and getting flooded with stupid pranks.

Our county attorney sent out a press release announcing that he's resigning to run for another office. We nearly blew it off as another stupid prank. It turns out the asshole really is resigning.

If I'm at one of those stations in Eugene -- and oddly enough I've worked at two of them, and used to shoot a lot of the Emeralds games -- I now doing everything in my power to get that PR person fired and an on-camera apology from the team. I would seriously consider ending coverage of the team until she's gone. The team needs the coverage far, far more than the station needs the team. At the very least, I do not speak to that PR person again in a professional capacity. We can see how much the owner enjoys taking all of my calls that used to go to the flak.

On a tangentially related note... man, did I love going to those games. Single A short-season baseball in a classic old wooden ballpark. Minor league baseball is vastly underrated, and far more entertaining than the big league version.
 
A daily I worked at some 10 years ago would actually do an April Fool's edition of the paper every year. Everything in the paper was legit except for the centerpiece stories on each front. The publisher loved it, even though the paper would be inundated with calls for a few days while people tried to put 2+2 together.

It was a small-town paper, and the one "prank" I remember was a story about Planet Hollywood buying out the very popular, very historic local diner. That one caused quite a ruckus.

Can't really recall the sports ones we did because the SE and myself weren't happy about giving what limited room we had to a fake story.
 
One other note on this...

The local news/talk radio radio station does a big April Fool's prank story every year. A few years ago it was that the state Dept. of Transportation was making all freeways in the area toll roads. The toll was determined by the number designation of the road: I-10 would be a dime per trip, but the Loop 101 would be $1.01. You were supposed to tally up how much you owed each month and then send a check.

People bought it, because (a) they're talk radio listeners, so most of them are morons, and (b) they had the PIO of the department on the air explaining how it would work and acknowledging that the DOT knew it would be unpopular, but that it needed the money.

He was suspended by the state, as I recall, and came within a hair of getting fired. He is by all accounts a great guy, and is generally very very good at his job. But wow, what a horrible lapse in judgment.
 
PCLoadLetter said:
On a tangentially related note... man, did I love going to those games. Single A short-season baseball in a classic old wooden ballpark. Minor league baseball is vastly underrated, and far more entertaining than the big league version.

Yeah, LOVE Ems games. Sadly, the old wooden ballpark is out this year: The Ems are moving to the UO ballpark after the school district announced it intends to sell Civic Stadium and the land as surplus property.
 
Add this to the mix.

http://blogs.post-trib.com/davich/2010/04/april-fools-day-joke-goes-awry.html


April Fools Day joke goes awry with angry, confused readers
By
Jerry Davich
on April 1, 2010 4:38 PM | Permalink | Comments (1)

It was only a joke.
Possibly a horrible joke. Possibly a great joke.
But it was simply an April Fools Day joke gone awry.

If you don't know what I'm talking about, it's probably a good thing or you too may be unhappy with me today.

On Wednesday night, I wrote on my online blog that I was fired from the Post-Tribune due to public backlash from a previous column.

That column, from Wednesday, compared Christian extremist militias with radical Islamic terrorist groups, and I received plenty of reader feedback - most positive, some negative, and one anonymous caller labeling me a "Commie pinko faggot." I kid you not (this time).
I also posted links to my blog via my Facebook and Twitter accounts late that night, as I do with most of my columns.


That entry, in part, read: "Post-Tribune columnist fired over sacrilegious column against Christians," followed by a brief summary of my mock termination and a farewell goodbye to my readers.

Minutes after I posted it online, I began receiving e-mails, texts, and online messages.

"Are you freaking kidding?!!!!!" wrote Candace Shaw on my Facebook page.
Yes, Candace, I was freaking kidding.
But too many readers didn't know this, even though I tried directing them to e-mail me, where they would receive a "APRIL
 FOOLS!" auto-reply.

Trouble is, most readers didn't follow my directive and instead believed I was fired.

"The actions which the Post-Tribune have taken are wrong, whether you agree or disagree with Mr. Davich's opinion. This is the final straw for me with mainstream media, which lets the dollar override the facts!" wrote one reader, echoing similar comments from others.

Even my own mother called me around midnight, asking if I just lost my job.
"Is it true?" she asked.
No, mom, it's not true. It was just a joke. Ha, ha, ha, ugh.

On Thursday morning I received more calls, including one from a P-T editor telling me that readers were already calling the office complaining.

I felt bad that my stupid little April Fools Day joke spun out of control and caused any hassles for P-T staffers and editors, so I wrote an in-house e-mail apology to them, explaining my intent.

The blog entry also prompted readers to leave disparaging comments, which then prompted my bosses to remove that entry entirely by mid-afternoon on Thursday. (You can read my original post further below).


But not before it served as an interesting experiment about knee-jerk reactions, misguided assumptions and, to be honest, appreciative support from readers of this column space.

Most of the feedback I received was supportive, but a few offered insights I never considered, such as this one from Tony Bianco.
"Good one Jerry! Although it says something about the present climate in this country that we could actually believe you could be fired for this," he said.
Interesting, huh?

Another reader jumped on that theme and ran with it, wryly noting, "The question is, why weren't we more surprised than we were? This must say something about today's job market."

Then again, I also received a call and e-mail saying "good riddance" to me, obviously from readers who don't like my columns.
"I've been waiting for the Post-Tribune to fire you for years," one reader told me. Ouch.

Other readers used this situation to vocalize their feelings about their own preferences and prejudices.
"It would appear that a number of readers are typical Fox News fans accustomed to swallowing any news without thinking," one reader said.

Quite a few readers didn't appreciate my attempt at humor at their expense.
"Surely Jerry Davich being fired over a 'sacrilegious' column is a joke... not a funny one at that," one reader said.
"I wasted an hour of my morning researching and responding to this rumor," one woman told me. "Bad Jerry, very bad Jerry."
Another one wrote, "Jerry, I'm writing from the emergency room at Porter. I had a heart attack when I heard what happened to you. Missed the humor."

Then again, several readers totally "got" my April Fools Day humor, including Facebook reader Lee Rademacher, who joked, "I knew it was all a scam since the entire editorial board is composed of commie pinkos."
And Michelle Quinn, a P-T correspondent who asked, "Can I have your desk?"

And a blog commenter who goes by the name of Rickie Surkamer, who wrote: "I am so glad to here they (PT) fired you. I have read some of your other stuff and it is total crap.
"I hope the word gets out in the industry about you and no one else makes the mistake of hiring you. I have the greatest respect and confidence in the top management of the POST-Trib. I highly praise them for firing you. You are an embarrassment to honest journalists."
Then, at the bottom of his post, similar to my blog post, he wrote, "APRIL FOOLS!!!!!!!!!"

Kudos to you, Rickie. You really had me for a minute.
Then again, I get similar e-mails somewhat frequently from readers. No foolin'.


On Wednesday afternoon, after Post-Tribune editors allegedly received an avalanche of feedback from angry readers regarding my column that day, I was fired by the top brass.



By Wednesday night, my desk was emptied (by a security guard), my office key was yanked from my hand (by a coworker who I will name later), and my computer was "intensely investigated" (by a company I.T. expert). This is a bunch of bull - - - -, I told them all.



The only concession allowed by management was to write one final blog entry (NOT one last column of course!) so this blog entry is it for me at the P-T.



It should be noted, however, that this blog entry is being reviewed, edited, and censored by management as I write it, but it's all I have to clear my name and my reputation regarding Wednesday's column.



That column, which can be found here, compared a "Christian militia" group called Hutaree to a radical Islamic terrorist group and, apparently, it prompted a public outcry from readers - Christian readers, that is.



"Davich should be held to the fire for this column or I'm cancelling my subscription," one disgruntled reader said.



"He's not a columnist, he's a communist," hissed another reader.



"How dare Mr. Davich write such a thing on Holy Week. He should be persecuted, or at least fired," another reader allegedly told my bosses.



I tried pleading my case to my editors, but obviously the decision was made long before I was allowed to defend myself, and my column. By the end of the work day, I was no longer a Post-Tribune employee.



By Wednesday night - after repeated requests to at least write this final blog entry to explain myself - I was drained by the whole stinking ordeal. As I write this - at 10:45 p.m. Wednesday - I feel it doesn't really matter what I say. I'm gone either way.



So, instead, I will write my reaction to this (unfair and illegal) dismissal after I leave this building and return home.



If anyone is interested in reading it, which will include details of my firing and behind-the-scenes insights on that column in question, email me at [email protected]. (I'm told that my email account will stay active through the week's end. And it had better or I'm hiring an attorney.)



Anyway, I want to thank the thousands of readers across Northwest Indiana who have regularly read my columns through the years, and who have supported my daily goal of revealing the truth (even if too much truth ended up costing me my job).



It's been a great adventure, and I'm very appreciative of you allowing me into your homes, your lives, and your hearts. Please feel free to email me with any feedback, reactions or, ahem, job leads. I'm sure I'll land on my feet somewhere.



Until then, thank you also for your time, your comments, and your loyalty.



Sincerely,



Jerry Davich

[email protected]
 
Deskhack said:
So, the local minor league baseball team (short-season Class A, Padres affiliate), the Eugene Emeralds, send out a press release last night saying that Jeremiah Masoli, disgraced Oregon quarterback, has signed to pitch for them this summer, at about 10:45 p.m. Turns out, though, that it's a joke perpetrated by the team. The local TV stations breathlessly report the hoax, leading their local newscasts with it, and the next day, everyone figures out that it's a joke.

The interesting thing about this? Apparently the TV stations called the PR flack who sent this out, and she confirmed the story. That's what gets me about this, the TV stations did their job as journalists and still got screwed over.

Did the team maybe go a little too far here? And should the flack maybe think about finding another line of work?

The team did go too far in this case, especially the PR lady in confirming the press release was true when asked about it.
Having said that, did the TV stations really do their job as journalists? Did they call Masoli or anyone at the UO? It should have taken at most 2 seconds to smell something odd, but the stories I saw from Wednesday night didn't seem to indicate anyone aside from the Ems got a call to confirm the details.
Long-term, this was a bad move, especially sending the release out right before the 11 p.m. news. Send it at 10, there's a chance TV people could reach someone at the UO to debunk it and everyone gets a laugh with no egg on the face. Now, TV got egg on the face last night and today threw the egg back at the team. Lot of bridge damage just for a joke.
 
hwkcrz1 said:
Add this to the mix.

http://blogs.post-trib.com/davich/2010/04/april-fools-day-joke-goes-awry.html


April Fools Day joke goes awry with angry, confused readers
By
Jerry Davich
on April 1, 2010 4:38 PM | Permalink | Comments (1)

It was only a joke.
Possibly a horrible joke. Possibly a great joke.
But it was simply an April Fools Day joke gone awry.

If you don't know what I'm talking about, it's probably a good thing or you too may be unhappy with me today.

On Wednesday night, I wrote on my online blog that I was fired from the Post-Tribune due to public backlash from a previous column.

That column, from Wednesday, compared Christian extremist militias with radical Islamic terrorist groups, and I received plenty of reader feedback - most positive, some negative, and one anonymous caller labeling me a "Commie pinko faggot." I kid you not (this time).
I also posted links to my blog via my Facebook and Twitter accounts late that night, as I do with most of my columns.


That entry, in part, read: "Post-Tribune columnist fired over sacrilegious column against Christians," followed by a brief summary of my mock termination and a farewell goodbye to my readers.

Minutes after I posted it online, I began receiving e-mails, texts, and online messages.

"Are you freaking kidding?!!!!!" wrote Candace Shaw on my Facebook page.
Yes, Candace, I was freaking kidding.
But too many readers didn't know this, even though I tried directing them to e-mail me, where they would receive a "APRIL
 FOOLS!" auto-reply.

Trouble is, most readers didn't follow my directive and instead believed I was fired.

"The actions which the Post-Tribune have taken are wrong, whether you agree or disagree with Mr. Davich's opinion. This is the final straw for me with mainstream media, which lets the dollar override the facts!" wrote one reader, echoing similar comments from others.

Even my own mother called me around midnight, asking if I just lost my job.
"Is it true?" she asked.
No, mom, it's not true. It was just a joke. Ha, ha, ha, ugh.

On Thursday morning I received more calls, including one from a P-T editor telling me that readers were already calling the office complaining.

I felt bad that my stupid little April Fools Day joke spun out of control and caused any hassles for P-T staffers and editors, so I wrote an in-house e-mail apology to them, explaining my intent.

The blog entry also prompted readers to leave disparaging comments, which then prompted my bosses to remove that entry entirely by mid-afternoon on Thursday. (You can read my original post further below).


But not before it served as an interesting experiment about knee-jerk reactions, misguided assumptions and, to be honest, appreciative support from readers of this column space.

Most of the feedback I received was supportive, but a few offered insights I never considered, such as this one from Tony Bianco.
"Good one Jerry! Although it says something about the present climate in this country that we could actually believe you could be fired for this," he said.
Interesting, huh?

Another reader jumped on that theme and ran with it, wryly noting, "The question is, why weren't we more surprised than we were? This must say something about today's job market."

Then again, I also received a call and e-mail saying "good riddance" to me, obviously from readers who don't like my columns.
"I've been waiting for the Post-Tribune to fire you for years," one reader told me. Ouch.

Other readers used this situation to vocalize their feelings about their own preferences and prejudices.
"It would appear that a number of readers are typical Fox News fans accustomed to swallowing any news without thinking," one reader said.

Quite a few readers didn't appreciate my attempt at humor at their expense.
"Surely Jerry Davich being fired over a 'sacrilegious' column is a joke... not a funny one at that," one reader said.
"I wasted an hour of my morning researching and responding to this rumor," one woman told me. "Bad Jerry, very bad Jerry."
Another one wrote, "Jerry, I'm writing from the emergency room at Porter. I had a heart attack when I heard what happened to you. Missed the humor."

Then again, several readers totally "got" my April Fools Day humor, including Facebook reader Lee Rademacher, who joked, "I knew it was all a scam since the entire editorial board is composed of commie pinkos."
And Michelle Quinn, a P-T correspondent who asked, "Can I have your desk?"

And a blog commenter who goes by the name of Rickie Surkamer, who wrote: "I am so glad to here they (PT) fired you. I have read some of your other stuff and it is total crap.
"I hope the word gets out in the industry about you and no one else makes the mistake of hiring you. I have the greatest respect and confidence in the top management of the POST-Trib. I highly praise them for firing you. You are an embarrassment to honest journalists."
Then, at the bottom of his post, similar to my blog post, he wrote, "APRIL FOOLS!!!!!!!!!"

Kudos to you, Rickie. You really had me for a minute.
Then again, I get similar e-mails somewhat frequently from readers. No foolin'.


On Wednesday afternoon, after Post-Tribune editors allegedly received an avalanche of feedback from angry readers regarding my column that day, I was fired by the top brass.



By Wednesday night, my desk was emptied (by a security guard), my office key was yanked from my hand (by a coworker who I will name later), and my computer was "intensely investigated" (by a company I.T. expert). This is a bunch of bull - - - -, I told them all.



The only concession allowed by management was to write one final blog entry (NOT one last column of course!) so this blog entry is it for me at the P-T.



It should be noted, however, that this blog entry is being reviewed, edited, and censored by management as I write it, but it's all I have to clear my name and my reputation regarding Wednesday's column.



That column, which can be found here, compared a "Christian militia" group called Hutaree to a radical Islamic terrorist group and, apparently, it prompted a public outcry from readers - Christian readers, that is.



"Davich should be held to the fire for this column or I'm cancelling my subscription," one disgruntled reader said.



"He's not a columnist, he's a communist," hissed another reader.



"How dare Mr. Davich write such a thing on Holy Week. He should be persecuted, or at least fired," another reader allegedly told my bosses.



I tried pleading my case to my editors, but obviously the decision was made long before I was allowed to defend myself, and my column. By the end of the work day, I was no longer a Post-Tribune employee.



By Wednesday night - after repeated requests to at least write this final blog entry to explain myself - I was drained by the whole stinking ordeal. As I write this - at 10:45 p.m. Wednesday - I feel it doesn't really matter what I say. I'm gone either way.



So, instead, I will write my reaction to this (unfair and illegal) dismissal after I leave this building and return home.



If anyone is interested in reading it, which will include details of my firing and behind-the-scenes insights on that column in question, email me at [email protected]. (I'm told that my email account will stay active through the week's end. And it had better or I'm hiring an attorney.)



Anyway, I want to thank the thousands of readers across Northwest Indiana who have regularly read my columns through the years, and who have supported my daily goal of revealing the truth (even if too much truth ended up costing me my job).



It's been a great adventure, and I'm very appreciative of you allowing me into your homes, your lives, and your hearts. Please feel free to email me with any feedback, reactions or, ahem, job leads. I'm sure I'll land on my feet somewhere.



Until then, thank you also for your time, your comments, and your loyalty.



Sincerely,



Jerry Davich

[email protected]

Good luck with that job search, Jerry.

There are plenty of journalists who aren't morons looking for work. Move to the back of the line, chief.
 
PR flak should be fired. Once the news organization called to see if it was true, the joke was up.
Disgraceful.
 
Was Jerry fired for his original column or the April Fools thing? I'm confused and thinking again I'm glad I've never taken part in any April Fools stuff.
 
Yeah it seemed like every two-bit sports station had a wacky trade to announce on their updates yesterday. Pulled into the minimart on the way to work in the middle of one and when I got back out to my car 5 minutes later, they guy was patting himself on the back on the air for how many gags he worked into the broadcast. Yeah, like we're supposed to believe him on his next "exclusive."
 
murphyc said:
Having said that, did the TV stations really do their job as journalists? Did they call Masoli or anyone at the UO? It should have taken at most 2 seconds to smell something odd, but the stories I saw from Wednesday night didn't seem to indicate anyone aside from the Ems got a call to confirm the details.

The release apparently went out at 10:45. That left exactly 15 minutes to confirm the story, write the story, edit video, and change the rundown of the newscast.

They got confirmation from a central player in the story. At that stage, that's as much as you could possibly ask for.

And not for nothing, this happened on March 31st, not April 1st.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top