What the heck, another HOF thread: Jason Witten?

[Baron Scicluna]

I wasn't thinking of him as a HOFamer until I saw a Cowboys game that had Witten listed as fourth all-time among tight ends in NFL history in career receptions. Stunned me because while I've known he was a very good player, I've never thought he was getting among the all-time leaders:

Tony Gonzalez 1,023 receptions and counting
Shannon Sharpe 815
Ozzie Newsome 662
Jason Witten 543 and counting.

Plus he's a six-time consecutive Pro Bowl selection and is tied with Kellen Winslow for the NFL record for most receptions by a tight end in a game with 15.

Part of me thinks he may be the victim of today's inflated reception stats (one more catch, and he passes J.T Smith for 85th on the all-time reception list by everyone. J.T. Smith). But part of me also thinks tight end is a unique position, and he would be a standout in any era.

Thoughts?

 

[bigpern23]

Those stats are surprising. I think that says a lot about Witten. Hall of Famers don't sneak up on you.

 

[TigerVols]

You'll get no argument from this Vol fanboi -- his daddy used to work for my dad.

 

[Ilmago]

It's hard to argue against his numbers but when talking tight ends you hit on a key point. Numbers are inflated in general but especially for TEs. There was a time they were practically extra lineman but now they've evolved to the point that some are basically super sized receivers.

When I heard this stat I was surprised he had more than Gates.

 

[nmmetsfan]

He needs another good 5-6 years. He's also a very good blocker, certainly better than the other three on that list, but stats are a TEs ticket to the HOF.

 

[JackReacher]

Jay Wit Dawg? No way.

 

[Football_Bat]

Witten will never sniff the HOF. He's not a Steeler. :D

 

[Blitz]

No way does he qualify for the football Hall of Fame.

 

[Mizzougrad96]

He needs several more seasons like he had in, I think, 2007 and 2008. He barely sniffed the end zone last year and playing with receivers like Austin, Williams and Bryant isn't going to help him either. He was Romo's go-to guy for a couple years, but I would argue he's not that guy anymore.

Sharpe is going to be the new benchmark for tight ends. If Witten winds up with number similar to Sharpe's he has a chance.

 

[93Devil]

Where are Dallas Clark and Antonio Gates on this list?

That would be four TEs from this generation who could get in. That might be one too many. But if Witten gets 750 catches, he is in.

 

[Mizzougrad96]

Where are Dallas Clark and Antonio Gates on this list?

That would be four TEs from this generation who could get in. That might be one too many. But if Witten gets 750 catches, he is in.

I think touchdowns will mean more than receptions, even though I pretty much agree with your assessment.

 

[mustangj17]

He's 85 all time in receptions. Needs to be higher than that. And he should be. I'm sure he has some good years ahead of him still.

 

[Stoney]

Part of me thinks he may be the victim of today's inflated reception stats (one more catch, and he passes J.T Smith for 85th on the all-time reception list by everyone. J.T. Smith). But part of me also thinks tight end is a unique position, and he would be a standout in any era.

He might still be a standout, but he wouldn't have nearly as many catches. Not sure any position has benefitted as much statistically from changes in the game as TE. They simply get far more balls thrown to them in today's offensive systems than the old ones where they were blockers first, recievers second.

 

[Football_Bat]

Part of me thinks he may be the victim of today's inflated reception stats (one more catch, and he passes J.T Smith for 85th on the all-time reception list by everyone. J.T. Smith). But part of me also thinks tight end is a unique position, and he would be a standout in any era.

He might still be a standout, but he wouldn't have nearly as many catches. Not sure any position has benefitted as much statistically from changes in the game as TE. They simply get far more balls thrown to them in today's offensive systems than the old ones where they were blockers first, recievers second.

As long as Romo is Dallas' QB, Witten will get catches. Although Roy Williams is finally starting to redeem himself, not that the win-loss record reflects that.