Thank you gifts from sources

[copperpot]

I never know how to handle this. I wrote a story last week about two local artists. They didn't solicit it -- I happened to stumble on a website of their work and contacted them. One just came by to say thank you and brought some baked goods as well as a pair of earrings she had hand crafted. Are these things OK to accept?

Thanks for the feedback.

 

[MTM]

Some may say no, but we have to use discretion.

I wrote an article about a man who had a high school stadium named after him and his son, who came from out of state for the dedication, asked me to lunch after it ran, and he paid and gave me his self-published book.

Although I probably shouldn't have let him pay, I didn't want to insult him and graciously accepted both.

I wouldn't have accepted either from a regular source, but since this was a onetime thing, I had no problem with it.

 

[dpfunk78]

You have to make a judgement call based on whether or not accepting a gift would or could create bias (or perceived bias) in the future. If you ever plan on working with the source again, I say you shouldn't accept anything.

If you're never going to write about this person again, though, use your own judgement. In all grey areas, I'd refuse all gifts.

 

[beanpole]

There's nothing wrong with putting the food out for everyone to share. I wouldn't accept the earrings, although some shops collect all such gifts and give them away to staff monthly or quarterly in a blind drawing.

There are plenty on here, however, that will tell you to grab all the freebees you can get. :

 

[RedCanuck]

In most cases, the people intend it to be a harmless, nice gesture and it's a gift that comes from the heart. For the time it takes to explain it and the likelihood of insulting them for refusing, in most cases, I'd say accept the baked goods or trinkets and enjoy them... or give them to a family member or charity if need be.

If it's an ongoing relationship, you probably want to be cautious about what you accept and what other people perceive of that gift - and if it's a corporate or team logo item, you really want to pick your spots.

 

[reformedhack]

Generally speaking, a policy of accepting no gifts is probably best. On the other hand, if it would be a personal insult to decline a gift -- specifically, a token gift of minimal value such as some baked goodies -- then go ahead and accept it.

If you absolutely have to decline a gift, then be overly polite about it. Don't spout dogma ("it's against our policy"), just treat the giver the way you'd want to be treated ("this is wonderful, thank you, but we're not allowed to accept gifts"). Put the onus on the company; don't make the giver feel bad about their actions.

Overall, consider the intent. A flower arrangement from a developer grateful for a publicity should be returned. A basket of daisies from a reader delighted that you noticed his 100th birthday doesn't need to be.

Gifts coming from a company or a publicist -- where it's obvious they're currying favor -- ought to be returned or donated their gift to charity, along with a note.

Two newsrooms ago, I was part of the committee that helped write an ethics policy. It mostly consisted of common sense -- treating people kindly, thinking about how the public might perceive your decisions -- but there was one entry that I was most proud of:

Perishables, by nature, don't need to be donated to charity. Food may be offered up for newsroom consumption, within reason.

 

[Versatile]

Generally speaking, a policy of accepting no gifts is probably best. On the other hand, if it would be a personal insult to decline a gift -- specifically, a token gift of minimal value such as some baked goodies -- then go ahead and accept it.

If you absolutely have to decline a gift, then be overly polite about it. Don't spout dogma ("it's against our policy"), just treat the giver the way you'd want to be treated ("this is wonderful, thank you, but we're not allowed to accept gifts"). Put the onus on the company; don't make the giver feel bad about their actions.

Overall, consider the intent. A flower arrangement from a developer grateful for a publicity should be returned. A basket of daisies from a reader delighted that you noticed his 100th birthday doesn't need to be.

Gifts coming from a company or a publicist -- where it's obvious they're currying favor -- ought to be returned or donated their gift to charity, along with a note.

Two newsrooms ago, I was part of the committee that helped write an ethics policy. It mostly consisted of common sense -- treating people kindly, thinking about how the public might perceive your decisions -- but there was one entry that I was most proud of:

Perishables, by nature, don't need to be donated to charity. Food may be offered up for newsroom consumption, within reason.

This, wholeheartedly.

I'm curious as to what everyone thinks about the possibility of copperpot actually going to the artist and offering to pay for the earrings? I would assume CP is done writing about the artist, so I think that would be acceptable. Otherwise, I would probably return the earrings while paying full compliments to the craftsmanship, just as reformedhack suggested.

If there's a good chance you'll be writing about this woman regularly, though, you simply can't accept the earrings at all and probably shouldn't have accepted the baked goods, either.

 

[Mizzougrad96]

Someone told me that Butch Davis sent Omaha steaks to all of the University of Miami beat writers one year. I heard only one of them refused the gift.

One year, I got a gift in the mail. I opened the card and saw that it was signed by the coach who I covered, a very prominent hoops coach.

I got really nervous because I was dreading the possibility of having to give it back.

It turned out to be a bobblehead... Of him...

It took me hours to stop laughing...

 

[Stitch]

I've received a few T-shirts. I'd rather receive a gift card to Chili's.

 

[PCLoadLetter]

If there's a good chance you'll be writing about this woman regularly, though, you simply can't accept the earrings at all and probably shouldn't have accepted the baked goods, either.

At some point we really need to step back, though, and realize that there's a lot of space between the Poynter-style Big J ethics commandments and the real world.

The reality is, if you reject baked goods, you are going to be written off as an impossibly rude asshole. And honestly, the hand-crafted earrings, unless they are of a particularly high value, are tough ones to say no to as well.

There's a big fat difference between, say, the politician offering suite tickets for the bowl game and the artist who baked cookies for you.

 

[finishthehat]

I once did a story on a guy -- my idea, not his -- and he got a bunch of business as a result.

He mailed me a thank you card with $500 cash in it.

We minutely documented me sending it back, including a photo of the bills being placed in a FedEx envelope.

 

[Mizzougrad96]

If there's a good chance you'll be writing about this woman regularly, though, you simply can't accept the earrings at all and probably shouldn't have accepted the baked goods, either.

At some point we really need to step back, though, and realize that there's a lot of space between the Poynter-style Big J ethics commandments and the real world.

The reality is, if you reject baked goods, you are going to be written off as an impossibly rude asshole. And honestly, the hand-crafted earrings, unless they are of a particularly high value, are tough ones to say no to as well.

There's a big fat difference between, say, the politician offering suite tickets for the bowl game and the artist who baked cookies for you.

When I covered preps, I did a big takeout on a volleyball player. Her dad worked at the deli of the local supermarket and he sent a deli tray to me at the paper as a thank you. I would have asked my boss if it was OK to keep it, but he was too busy stuffing his face to answer.

 

[2underpar]

I wrote a column once about my first hole-in-one. The caveat was i made it playing by myself early one morning. The gist of the column was "crap, I finally make an ace and nobody was around to see it."
A guy who owned a local gas station sent me a gift certificate for $10 worth of free gas. Said nobody should be that unlucky.
yeah, i used it.

 

[Oggiedoggie]

I got a rock!

 

[playthrough]

I wrote a column once about my first hole-in-one. The caveat was i made it playing by myself early one morning. The gist of the column was "crap, I finally make an ace and nobody was around to see it."
A guy who owned a local gas station sent me a gift certificate for $10 worth of free gas. Said nobody should be that unlucky.
yeah, i used it.

Man, that's my worst nightmare as a golfer. Great story though.

 

[SFIND]

Generally speaking, a policy of accepting no gifts is probably best. On the other hand, if it would be a personal insult to decline a gift -- specifically, a token gift of minimal value such as some baked goodies -- then go ahead and accept it.

If you absolutely have to decline a gift, then be overly polite about it. Don't spout dogma ("it's against our policy"), just treat the giver the way you'd want to be treated ("this is wonderful, thank you, but we're not allowed to accept gifts"). Put the onus on the company; don't make the giver feel bad about their actions.

Overall, consider the intent. A flower arrangement from a developer grateful for a publicity should be returned. A basket of daisies from a reader delighted that you noticed his 100th birthday doesn't need to be.

Gifts coming from a company or a publicist -- where it's obvious they're currying favor -- ought to be returned or donated their gift to charity, along with a note.

Here 'tis -- the guidelines I go by.

 

[Smasher_Sloan]

Stay away from homemade baked goods. The baker may be a smoker or someone who keeps a lot of pets.

That's the rule you need to follow.

 

[Versatile]

If there's a good chance you'll be writing about this woman regularly, though, you simply can't accept the earrings at all and probably shouldn't have accepted the baked goods, either.

At some point we really need to step back, though, and realize that there's a lot of space between the Poynter-style Big J ethics commandments and the real world.

The reality is, if you reject baked goods, you are going to be written off as an impossibly rude asshole. And honestly, the hand-crafted earrings, unless they are of a particularly high value, are tough ones to say no to as well.

There's a big fat difference between, say, the politician offering suite tickets for the bowl game and the artist who baked cookies for you.

When I covered preps, I did a big takeout on a volleyball player. Her dad worked at the deli of the local supermarket and he sent a deli tray to me at the paper as a thank you. I would have asked my boss if it was OK to keep it, but he was too busy stuffing his face to answer.

I was talking explicitly about regular sources, and I meant more on the news side than sports. I'm thinking that city council member who your paper endorsed and you wrote a feature on during the election who wins the spot and brings you some baked goods. Then, yeah, you should reject it if you're the city council reporter.

 

[Tarheel316]

I've received a few T-shirts. I'd rather receive a gift card to Chili's.

I'd prefer Red Robin over Chili's.lol

 

[Azrael]

A polite 'no' to everything.