Reporters as fans

Sports Journalists Forum – Media, Newsroom & Reporting Talk

Help Support Sports Journalists Forum:

MTM

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2006
Messages
8,102
I know we've discused this before, but here is an interesting back and forth started by a former, longtime reporter. It's a fine line. We all at least started as fans, and many still are. I'd post about my team on my personal Facebook page but not on my professional account.



 
I tried my best to be a fan of the fast clock and a good game, for a good story. Otherwise I didn't give a flip.

Homers abound, though.

When working on deadline, I always was a fan of a fast clock. Hated extra innings, overtime, and especially shootouts in the NHL. For some reason, the AP would always take twice as long to send gamers for NHL games that finished in a shootout.
 
Hell, half the reason I became a Caps diehard was that I never covered hockey, at least not when I got back to Virginia. (Covered a handful of Coyotes games in Arizona, mostly in the playoffs.) I felt like I could be a fan without any restrictor plates. It was tricky in college sports, especially considering I spent a decent amount of time as a beat writer covering my alma mater and my alma mater's bitter rival. Never thought I let it affect my reporting, though when I voted for the AP Top 25 in hoops and had Virginia at No. 5 -- which many Cavs fans felt was too low -- they were quick to point out I went to Virginia Tech and gave me plenty of **** for it. Didn't bother me much, though.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
The preps guy isn't allowed to pull for his local pro team? I can't lose sleep over that. And I'm sure not picking a fight with him on Twitter over it.
Seems like he's trying to make an issue of it. His tweet alleging that newsrooms are full of people wearing gear of their teams seems false. The ones I was in weren't like that. Of course people had their teams, but they had the good sense to not brazenly root in professional settings.

Are there professional settings anymore?
 
Honestly, sports "journalism" empires have been built on being fanbois - ask Simmons and Portnoy.

I do think its odd how newspapers and such will advertise as "the official" whatever of X Teams fans (of course, they don't have to pay a dime for the designation) and also how fans expect the local sports news people to "root" for their team, publish nothing but puff pieces and go easy when bad news comes along. And we've also come to an era where someone will stake out the turf of the "anti-homer" just to get clicks.
 
I'm a firm believer in no cheering in the press box. But I also understand that bias inevitably creeps in because we are all human beings. If you take a job somewhere and aren't remotely a fan of the team you cover, eventually you form relationships with the individuals involved. Maybe you connect really well with the linemen or hit it off with the coach.

Even by staying completely professional, you're going to eventually be in a position where a part of you will want them to succeed, just on a human level. Or, if they get fired, it's going to impact you more than if it was someone you never met.

We all have biases. The key is either disclosing those biases (dropping "AT&T WarnerMedia is the parent company of CNN" in news report by the cable network, for example) or by having checks in place to ensure bias doesn't color the story.

Unfortunately, with more and more cuts to newsrooms, those checks are disappearing.

I think you can grow up a Seahawks fan and still cover the team fairly. I don't think you should be cheering in the press box or wearing team gear.

Oh, and pontificating about this on social media gets you nowhere, Tom Hoffarth. The only people who care are other journalists, because all the fans can't understand how you're not a fan of the team in the first place.
 
Seems like he's trying to make an issue of it. His tweet alleging that newsrooms are full of people wearing gear of their teams seems false. The ones I was in weren't like that. Of course people had their teams, but they had the good sense to not brazenly root in professional settings.

Are there professional settings anymore?

The newsrooms I remember, outside of sports, didn't have people wearing gear. Because none of them would have known the teams were playing. They took great pride in not reading sports and of course on election night acted like they were journalism warriors because they had to work past midnight.

(Sorry, I figure it's been a while around here since someone bashed the election-night newssiders and their pizza. They all need to get off my lawn.)
 
I’m just laughing at the thought of someone telling a newly-minted Alabama or Ohio State grad who hired in as a preps writer they couldn’t root for the Tide or Buckeyes in their spare time in the year 2022.

“Please stop doing the thing that your entire identity revolves around for this job that pays $12 an hour with ****ty insurance.”

A preps writer? Keep it off social media and your writing, but this industry is too ****ty at this point to start shearing off the things you love.

I was the weirdo in Ohio because I was a preps writer who didn’t root for Ohio State football.
 
Last edited:
I think you can root for something while also being objective about who and what they are.
Anyone who has read my posts here on Pitt football knows that (1) I want them to win (2) I'm a helluva' lot more critical of them than any rival school's fan could ever be. Hell, I'm heading to Atlantic City this weekend to cash the bet I made AGAINST them in the Western Michigan game. How ya' like that for objectivity?
It's the ones who pledge blind loyalty to a team that are the real problem, and there seem to be a ton of those on college beats.
 
It's OK to be a fan. Depending on the job, being a drooling fan on social media might be a bad look. Are you a preps reporter rooting for a pro team? Or are you an editor rooting for a local team? In general, I would be careful. Some fans, perhaps the silly minority, see your fandom as proof all media hates their team.
 
Thankfully, I've never worked in a newsroom where wearing sports gear to work would be deemed appropriate attire. Honestly, if you're a professional you should dress like a professional. You don't know who you're going to meet or come across on a given day when you work for a news org.
 
There was an infamous thread here years ago about a Pittsburgh sports writer who was wearing PSU clothing to cover Pitt, perhaps as a protest to being moved onto the beat.
 
Many many years ago I learned that one way to stop rooting for a team was to cover it for awhile. Exposed to the usual mixture of good, bad, and maddening experiences that surround any team knocks the stars from your eyes pretty quickly.
Can I like this +100 times?
 

Latest posts

Back
Top