No, he goes in along with the Bonds and ArodYankeeFan said:Busted twice for banned substances. Does that completely ruin his chance of getting in the Hall?
Both were towards the end of his career, but it's going to be hard for most voters to overlook getting caught twice.
MightyMouse said:So given the choice between rehab and retirement, he chose retirement. With any other player, this might have surprised me. But, hey, it's Manny.
JC said:No, he goes in along with the Bonds and ArodYankeeFan said:Busted twice for banned substances. Does that completely ruin his chance of getting in the Hall?
Both were towards the end of his career, but it's going to be hard for most voters to overlook getting caught twice.
Dead serious.YankeeFan said:JC said:No, he goes in along with the Bonds and ArodYankeeFan said:Busted twice for banned substances. Does that completely ruin his chance of getting in the Hall?
Both were towards the end of his career, but it's going to be hard for most voters to overlook getting caught twice.
Are you being serious or sarcastic?
YankeeFan said:Busted twice for banned substances. Does that completely ruin his chance of getting in the Hall?
Both were towards the end of his career, but it's going to be hard for most voters to overlook getting caught twice.
Manny Ramirez retired from baseball Friday instead of facing a 100-game suspension for testing positive for a performance-enhancing drug, according to two people briefed on the matter.
Ramirez tested positive for the performance-enhancing drug during spring training and was recently informed of the positive result, according to the people.
In a news release, the commissioner’s office said it had recently notified Ramirez “of an issue under Major League Baseball’s Joint Drug Prevention and Treatment Program.”
The statement added, “Rather than continue with the process under the Program, Ramirez has informed M.L.B. that he is retiring as an active player.”
The commissioner’s office said that if Ramirez wanted to return to baseball, he would have to face discipline for his positive test.
http://bats.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/04/08/ramirez-retires-after-testing-positive/?hp
bigpern23 said:Eh, actually, I'd like amend my statement. After getting caught three times, Manny can't be considered a Hall of Famer of cheating. An Alvaro Espinoza of Cheating, perhaps.
So you don't think Bonds and AROD get in? I'd take that wager.YankeeFan said:bigpern23 said:Eh, actually, I'd like amend my statement. After getting caught three times, Manny can't be considered a Hall of Famer of cheating. An Alvaro Espinoza of Cheating, perhaps.
Yeah, I had forgotten that he was one of the ones who tested positive in '03 without consequences.
So, that's three times. I don't see how he gets in, unless years later they put in a host of steroids users from that era.
I don't think the current voters will put him in.
How do you vote for the other 2 and not Manny?Flying Headbutt said:I think Bonds and AROD get in. I have major doubts about Manny now.
JC said:How do you vote for the other 2 and not Manny?Flying Headbutt said:I think Bonds and AROD get in. I have major doubts about Manny now.
me personally, I'd put them all in. I don't live in naive Pollyanna land. The vast majority of the players in this era were taking something.YankeeFan said:JC said:How do you vote for the other 2 and not Manny?Flying Headbutt said:I think Bonds and AROD get in. I have major doubts about Manny now.
That's what's so tough about all of this.
I don't think any of them go in. If you're not putting McGwire or Sosa in, how do you put them in?