How to cover HS tranfers?

[User 6659]

So a stud athlete transferred from one of our area HS to another, supposedly moving from his mom's house to his dad's. We didn't even run an entire article about it, but rather just a sentence in a "looking ahead to next season" story after the recent baseball season ended.

The next day, this kid's mom called and was PISSED, saying the kid's dad didn't have custody and wouldn't until he took her to court. But we had it from four good sources, including the kid's coaches at his old school, coaches at the new school (a stud middle linebacker and wrestler), and several athletes from his old school. The only person we hadn't talked to was the kid himself and his parents. I know this was dumb, but I didn't write the story, so don't chastise me for it.

Should these transfer stories be covered beforehand, or should we have waited until he was actually on the practice field for the new team?

 

[PeteyPirate]

So a stud athlete transferred from one of our area HS to another, supposedly moving from his mom's house to his dad's. We didn't even run an entire article about it, but rather just a sentence in a "looking ahead to next season" story after the recent baseball season ended.

The next day, this kid's mom called and was PISSED, saying the kid's dad didn't have custody and wouldn't until he took her to court. But we had it from four good sources, including the kid's coaches at his old school, coaches at the new school (a stud middle linebacker and wrestler), and several athletes from his old school. The only person we hadn't talked to was the kid himself and his parents. I know this was dumb, but I didn't write the story, so don't chastise me for it.

Should these transfer stories be covered beforehand, or should we have waited until he was actually on the practice field for the new team?

I'm not sure the father not having custody and the kid's legal residence being his dad's house are mutually exclusive, but I could be wrong.

 

[Ace]

I wouldn't have run it until I talked to the kid or his parents.

And anytime a kid is supposedly going from one parent to another you couldn't have a much bigger red flag than that.

You know one parent is probably going to be pissed and lash out. It's not a done deal until he starts the new school.

So, I would have waited until he enrolled or I talked to him and/or his parents.

 

[PeteyPirate]

He did transfer, right? If so, you didn't get it wrong.

 

[User 6659]

He did transfer, right? If so, you didn't get it wrong.

Well, the only person that said he hasn't is his mom. But he hasn't actually started school there, because he wasn't transferring until after the school year

 

[zebracoy]

If he's enrolled at the school, you're fine. If he hasn't .... uh-oh.

But yeah, at least you know you should have talked to the kid. Though how that got through the editing process without someone catching that is beyond me.

 

[Saint Lou]

I wouldn't have run it until I talked to the kid or his parents.

It doesn't matter how many sources you have on something like this if you haven't talked to the kid or his parents.

You wait until you talk to the kid or he officially enrolls in the new school. Things can change pretty quickly on a deal like this.

 

[Editude]

Unless you have an actual copy of the transfer/enrollment at the new school, you need to talk to the family. The switching-between-parents-houses transfer approach is rife with abuse and eligibility questions.

 

[Jake_Taylor]

The switching-between-parents-houses transfer approach is rife with abuse and eligibility questions.

No kidding. I was talking to a parent about a month ago and he wasn't sure if his kid would be able to go to the school he wanted. No problem, he and his wife were prepared to get legally seperated and rent an apartment in the other school district.

 

[zagoshe]

The rule of thumb should be simple -- don't report it until said kid is enrolled in school, attending practices and classes and you know for a fact he is where "sources" say he is.

 

[Clerk Typist]

The switching-between-parents-houses transfer approach is rife with abuse and eligibility questions.

No kidding. I was talking to a parent about a month ago and he wasn't sure if his kid would be able to go to the school he wanted. No problem, he and his wife were prepared to get legally seperated and rent an apartment in the other school district.

Jake, that's an even better story. The lengths parents go to to further the careers (and, I guess, college scholarship prospects) of their little ones. Let's see, "For richer or poorer, in sickness and in health, unless Johnny has a shot to go to Tech State and there's a kid in front of him as a senior, and then we'll split so he can transfer to Podunk Prep."

 

[Jake_Taylor]

The switching-between-parents-houses transfer approach is rife with abuse and eligibility questions.

No kidding. I was talking to a parent about a month ago and he wasn't sure if his kid would be able to go to the school he wanted. No problem, he and his wife were prepared to get legally seperated and rent an apartment in the other school district.

Jake, that's an even better story. The lengths parents go to to further the careers (and, I guess, college scholarship prospects) of their little ones. Let's see, "For richer or poorer, in sickness and in health, unless Johnny has a shot to go to Tech State and there's a kid in front of him as a senior, and then we'll split so he can transfer to Podunk Prep."

Oh, I know. It's crazy. Nothing came of this case, but there is a new school opening soon in my neck of the woods and it will be very interesting to see which athletes are going where and if they are going where they are suppossed to.

 

[RossLT]

We had a kid who transferred because he didn't like a coach at one school, the high school sports organization made him sit for a year because it was obvious he transferred for athletics. My SE told me had he said the old school did not offer a program that the new school did he would have been eligible, anyone know anything about this kind of thing being true?

 

[Stitch]

There were a couple of athletes at my high school that took ROTC since the other school in the district didn't offer it.

 

[Ace]

We had a kid who transferred because he didn't like a coach at one school, the high school sports organization made him sit for a year because it was obvious he transferred for athletics. My SE told me had he said the old school did not offer a program that the new school did he would have been eligible, anyone know anything about this kind of thing being true?

Yes. If you transfer for "academic" reasons or change residences, you don't have to sit out.

 

[Bob Slydell]

I wouldn't have run it until I talked to the kid or his parents.

It doesn't matter how many sources you have on something like this if you haven't talked to the kid or his parents.

You wait until you talk to the kid or he officially enrolls in the new school. Things can change pretty quickly on a deal like this.

Agreed. If the kid stays at his current school, yo look atupid of you hadn;t talked to them.

But if they told you he was transferring, and he stays, you're good.

 

[MCbamr]

We had a kid who transferred because he didn't like a coach at one school, the high school sports organization made him sit for a year because it was obvious he transferred for athletics. My SE told me had he said the old school did not offer a program that the new school did he would have been eligible, anyone know anything about this kind of thing being true?

Yes. If you transfer for "academic" reasons or change residences, you don't have to sit out.

Not in every state. In Louisiana, "academic reasons" still means sitting out a year unless it's done before ninth grade or a few other exceptions.

 

[Ace]

We had a kid who transferred because he didn't like a coach at one school, the high school sports organization made him sit for a year because it was obvious he transferred for athletics. My SE told me had he said the old school did not offer a program that the new school did he would have been eligible, anyone know anything about this kind of thing being true?

Yes. If you transfer for "academic" reasons or change residences, you don't have to sit out.

Not in every state. In Louisiana, "academic reasons" still means sitting out a year unless it's done before ninth grade or a few other exceptions.

Of course. Whose going to switch schools for academic reasons in Louisiana? ;)

 

[Editude]

At a former stop, a common way around the can't-transfer-for-sports rule was to sign up for the IB program at a noted wrestling power, enroll and then drop the program.

 

[pressmurphy]

I got burned by one of these deals once on the best athlete we'd had in at least 15 years. I had everything nailed -- even had a confirmation from the superintendent of the kid's new district that the paperwork had been received -- but didn't have a quote from the kid or his family.

Wrote it in late July. Come early September, he was still at his old school.

Technically, I had everything right (except for the first-person confirmation), but I had to chalk it up as a blunder rather than a scoop.

Reiterating what's already been said: Get it from the horse's mouth.