50 Bands, 50 States

[Inky_Wretch]

Boston Phoenix lists the best band, solo act and new band from all 50 states ...

http://thephoenix.com/Supplements/2008/50States/

 

[Batman]

OK, I get wanting to name a bluesman for Mississippi. And Robert Johnson vs. B.B. King is like arguing whether you like vanilla ice cream or strawberry. Either way, you're getting a treat.
But either of them over Elvis Freaking Presley? Are you kidding me?
They lost me right there.

 

[Inky_Wretch]

Exactly my thinking too.

Of course, it is the Phoenix and it's got to be edgy and hip. Picking Elvis would make the hipsters roll their eyes and question the paper's cred.

 

[Batman]

It's odd. I looked at most of the other states, and it was a pretty good cross-section of genres. Lots of country acts, R&B, rock. Granted, I've never heard of any of the "best new bands" and a lot of the "best bands" had me scratching my head as to who the hell they were. Maybe I'm just not cool enough. It just seems like they missed the boat on that one.

 

[Beaker]

There's nothing wrong with the Pixies, but like Inky said, the Phoenix just has to be the Phoenix...I mean no matter what you think of them, you can't pick the Pixies over bands like Aerosmith or Boston etc. for best all time band from MA.

 

[DougDascenzo]

OK, I get wanting to name a bluesman for Mississippi. And Robert Johnson vs. B.B. King is like arguing whether you like vanilla ice cream or strawberry. Either way, you're getting a treat.
But either of them over Elvis Freaking Presley? Are you kidding me?
They lost me right there.

You were lost long ago if you think Elvis Presley is a better artist than Robert Johnson or BB King.

Go back to the bat-cave and download!

 

[NoOneLikesUs]

I know Trent Renzor was born in Pennsylvania, but most of his early work was done in Ohio.

Some of these states have sad contributions.

 

[Angola!]

Much to the chagrin of multiple board members, Nirvana was chosen for Washington. How it beat out Pearl Jam, I'm not sure.

 

[Batman]

OK, I get wanting to name a bluesman for Mississippi. And Robert Johnson vs. B.B. King is like arguing whether you like vanilla ice cream or strawberry. Either way, you're getting a treat.
But either of them over Elvis Freaking Presley? Are you kidding me?
They lost me right there.

You were lost long ago if you think Elvis Presley is a better artist than Robert Johnson or BB King.

Go back to the bat-cave and download!

And you go back to Wrigley and hit .220!
Any one of those three is a good choice. If you go strictly blues, you go with Johnson or King. But when you're looking at the combination of talent, impact and even folklore (Johnson's deal with the devil is great, but Elvis has tons of stories about him that make him larger than life) there's one name that pops to mind.

 

[dixiehack]

REM over the Allman Brothers in Georgia? Discuss.

 

[Angola!]

Everybody Hurts, even the Allman Brothers?

 

[pallister]

Interesting list, Inky. I love discovering new music, but, for me, this list wasn't very helpful. I went through all 50 states (except W. Va.; link wasn't working) and wrote down 8 bands I thought were worth giving another listen. I hadn't even heard of many of the state's "best." Alabama was the only state for which I knew and enjoyed the best band and best artist and liked the must-see selection.

Also, while I'm not a huge Dylan fan, a toss-up between him and Prince? Please, that's ridiculous. The man's influence on music cannot be overstated.

 

[imjustagirl]

The man's influence on music cannot be overstated.

Prince's? You're right.

 

[pallister]

Booooooooo!

 

[imjustagirl]

The truth hurts, Sox fan.

(and yes, I remember the score from last night. Asshole.)

 

[SportsDude]

Guided By Voices should win Ohio in a sweep.

And I do love Screamin' Jay Hawkins.

 

[spnited]

I loves me some Four Seasons, but seriously how can they and the Misfits be the toss-up for best NJ band.

They named Bruce the best solo act when in fact Bruce and the E-Streeters are the best band out of NJ and the best solo act was that skinny crooner from Hoboken named Sinatra.

 

[imjustagirl]

I've never heard of any of the people/bands mentioned for Kentucky.

 

[JayFarrar]

Big Black for best band out of Illinois?!?
Seriously?
The Boston Phoenix is retarded.

And Spnited, totally agree. Plus, I thought Sinatra had gotten all edgy and cool with the hipster douchebags again. So him being left out is a little odd.

 

[pallister]

I'm surprised one the must-see bands wasn't named Hipster Douchebags.