2021 Baseball Hall of Fame Class

Sports Journalists Forum – Media, Newsroom & Reporting Talk

Help Support Sports Journalists Forum:

Della9250

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2002
Messages
21,807
I think this is a stupid idea, especially because several of the candidates have a decent chance to pass away between now and the 2022 induction but whatever.

It's also stupid because there are going to be no modern candidates elected -- the first-timers fall well short and the only holdover who has a chance is Schilling, so good luck with that.



The board of directors of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum has voted unanimously to reschedule this winter’s two Era Committee elections because of concerns associated with the COVID-19 pandemic.

Hall of Fame Chairman Jane Forbes Clark says the Era Committee process requires in-person dialogue involving the members of the 16-person voting committee. In view of those concerns, she said the board decided that the Golden Days Committee and the Early Days Committee will instead meet during the winter of 2021.

The Golden Days Era Committee considers Hall of Fame candidates whose primary contributions to the game came from 1950 to 1969, and the Early Baseball Era Committee considers candidates whose primary contributions came prior to 1950. Each committee will consider a ballot of 10 candidates compiled by the Baseball Writers’ Association of America’s Historical Overview Committee, and those candidates will be announced in autumn 2021. Both committees will consider the ballots later that year and anybody elected will be enshrined in 2022.
 
Everyone on the Early Baseball ballot is dead but the last Golden Days ballot (which was held in 2014) had these candidates, with their current ages:

Maury Wills, 87, missed by three votes
Tony Oliva, 82, missed by a vote
Jim Kaat, 81, missed by two votes
Luis Tiant, 79
**** Allen, 78, missed by a vote

Dead
Minnie Miñoso, missed by four votes
Ken Boyer
Gil Hodges
Bob Howsam
Billy Pierce
 
The problem is that the Today's Game committee ballot is for players who can't be on eligible for it until their maximum time of the regular ballot would have expired. So if they were voting this year, anyone who played after 1988 and retired 2004 in 2004 is eligible. It is an extremely narrow scope and that showed when there were three managers and an owner among the 10 candidates.

The Modern Era Ballot (1970-87) will be interesting next time around. Two spots are open with Miller and Simmons to be inducted and Whitaker probably has to be viewed as the top choice among the holdovers.

Also, to be fair, the regular voters are doing a pretty good job of electing people who should be elected. Outside of steroid-tainted guys and Pete Rose for the obvious reasons, there aren't a lot of guys in that started after 1970, retired before 2004 range who should be in. There are a couple of notable misses.

How much of a clamor should there be for say, this list:

Munson
Grich
Whitaker
Evans
McGriff, who will be eligible for the next Today's Game ballot.


And then realize that the people picking the Today's Game ballot though the best six were Baines, Bells, Carter, Clark, Hershiser and Smith and the last Modern Ballot had Evans, Garvey, John, Mattingly, Munson, Murphy, Parker, and Whitaker
 
Spink Award Finalists

**** Kaegel
Marty Noble
Allan Simpson

All newcomers as finalists, jumping Patrick Reusse and Jim Reeves from last year
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
So is Joe Buck going to get a double induction this year?

I don't like giving it to guys still working.

Michaels seems like an obvious choice: three other guys are dead and there's a chance he wouldn't make it to the next induction ceremony for this category
 
There's nobody on that list who would be worse than the worst player already in the Hall. At some point, the Expansion Era is going to need to be adequately represented.

There's probably nobody on the list who would be among the worst 20 players in the HOF if inducted.
 
So is Joe Buck going to get a double induction this year?

I don't like giving it to guys still working.

Michaels seems like an obvious choice: three other guys are dead and there's a chance he wouldn't make it to the next induction ceremony for this category
I’m with you on this. No one working should go in
 
My problem with Michaels is he hasn't done baseball regularly in about 30 years, when CBS took over the contract.
 
Frick Award Finalists

Buddy Blattner
Joe Buck
Dave Campbell
Dizzy Dean
Don Drysdale
Ernesto Jerez
Al Michaels
Dan Shulman

2021 Ford C. Frick Award Ballot

Blattner and Dean are before my time and I'm not familiar with Jerez, but do any of the others really belong in the HoF? Drysdale was a decent broadcaster, so is Shulman. Buck and Michaels both have done a lot of big games, but are/were they outstanding? I remember liking Campbell years ago, but can't remember why.
 
I really don't understand the need for "in-person" meeting for the old-timers - unless those voting/deciding are Zoom-incapable.
 
Ballot is out. It is smaller than usual, just 25 names:

Bobby Abreu
Barry Bonds
Mark Buehrle
A.J. Burnett
Roger Clemens
Michael Cuddyer
Dan Haren
LaTroy Hawkins
Todd Helton
Tim Hudson
Torii Hunter
Andruw Jones
Jeff Kent
Andy Pettitte
Aramis Ramírez
Manny Ramirez
Scott Rolen
Curt Schilling
Gary Sheffield
Sammy Sosa
Nick Swisher
Shane Victorino
Omar Vizquel
Billy Wagner
Barry Zito
 
A lot HOFers when it comes to having problems/being a-holes with the media on that list,
 

If you have a slash line that has the following over a long career, you’re HOF .3xx/.4xx/.5xx. Period. End of story. Add 12 time All Star. WS MVP. 9 Silver Slugger. Don’t vote for him means you don’t know much about baseball. And you probably got your job on your knees

it’s time to end the charade. Bonds McGwire Clemens are all HOF.

under the Harold Baines rule it’s time to let in the Hall of Very Good or make a clear stand that it was close to an abomination and set the bar even higher.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top