Why the Beatles "Rock Band" hype is worthwhile

Sports Journalists Forum – Media, Newsroom & Reporting Talk

Help Support Sports Journalists Forum:

Twoback

Active Member
Joined
Dec 15, 2003
Messages
6,141
So much of what the self-reverential 60s generation produced and/or worshipped has been overhyped beyond all reason.
Dylan.
Ali.
Woodstock.
Janis Joplin.
Mickey Mantle.
But not the Beatles. The Beatles, love them, like them or loathe them, were brilliant. Undeniably brilliant. This from someone who's never bought one of their records.
 
Agree with all you posted, Twoback, aside from the whole not buying their records thing. I would also add that they were innovative as can be in the studio. Just an amazingly creative bunch.

But the reason for the "Rock Band" hype being worthwhile is even simpler: Because whenever one of these games comes out, especially the band-specific ones, they are always excellent.

Guitar Hero: Metallica was the advanced band version. And I suspect Guitar Hero: Van Halen will be similar, just for those without as much stamina.

Rock Band: Beatles is for those who want to have a great time, and appreciate some incredible music.

Some bands (cough, Led Zeppelin, cough) refuse to get into this video game thing. Others (cough, Beatles, cough) are resisting iTunes. Both are undeniably effective ways of getting classic music to today's consumers.
 
I love the Beattles, but I'll admit they're over-hyped.
Dylan = not over-hyped
 
Buck said:
I love the Beattles, but I'll admit they're over-hyped.
Dylan = not over-hyped

Whatever you've been drinking, I'll take a double.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Piotr Rasputin said:
Agree with all you posted, Twoback, aside from the whole not buying their records thing. I would also add that they were innovative as can be in the studio. Just an amazingly creative bunch.

But the reason for the "Rock Band" hype being worthwhile is even simpler: Because whenever one of these games comes out, especially the band-specific ones, they are always excellent.

Guitar Hero: Metallica was the advanced band version. And I suspect Guitar Hero: Van Halen will be similar, just for those without as much stamina.

Rock Band: Beatles is for those who want to have a great time, and appreciate some incredible music.

Some bands (cough, Led Zeppelin, cough) refuse to get into this video game thing. Others (cough, Beatles, cough) are resisting iTunes. Both are undeniably effective ways of getting classic music to today's consumers.

From virtually all reports, the Beatles themselves (Paul, Ringo, Yoko and Olivia) all want the songs released to iTunes. It's the other ****ing ****ers who have gotten their fingers into control of the catalog who are hanging it up. Remember, it was nearly a decade after CDs burst on the scene before the catalog went to disc.
 
Sign no. 90210 I am old: I don't get Rock Band or Guitar Hero. At all. Or how there's money to be made by the Beatles, VH, et al, in selling their catalog to the games.

Here, have a wiffle bat. Boom. Now you have an air guitar. Now go out and play in the ****ing sun, you stupid kids.
 
I did it like this, I did it like that, I did it with a whiffle ball bat, so...
 
BYH said:
Sign no. 90210 I am old: I don't get Rock Band or Guitar Hero. At all. Or how there's money to be made by the Beatles, VH, et al, in selling their catalog to the games.

Here, have a wiffle bat. Boom. Now you have an air guitar. Now go out and play in the ****ing sun, you stupid kids.

Outstanding.

(I feel the same way, for the record.)
 
buckweaver said:
BYH said:
Sign no. 90210 I am old: I don't get Rock Band or Guitar Hero. At all. Or how there's money to be made by the Beatles, VH, et al, in selling their catalog to the games.

Here, have a wiffle bat. Boom. Now you have an air guitar. Now go out and play in the ****ing sun, you stupid kids.

Outstanding.

(I feel the same way, for the record.)

I felt the same way ... until I played the game. It's kinda fun. I wouldn't spend money on it. But if a friend has it and I'm at their house, I'll play it.
 
If a friend has it, I'll play it, too. But it's one of those games I'd get bored with pretty quickly.
 
Games are a matter of taste. I enjoy the various Guitar Hero games, especially Metallica. They're not everyone's cup of tea, but they great party games because everyone enjoys music, and four at a time can play these games: Drums, Two guitars, singer. Have had a couple of great marathons playing the game with a group of friends.

There is a lot of money to be made for the bands. Check the list of individual bands' top iTunes downloads. More often than not, a song's appearance on a video game will put its downloads through the roof. Like when "Don't Stop Believin'" was on the Sopranos.

With CD sales way down, and radio an utter wasteland (classic rock stations' motto should be "If you have heard it a million times, you'll hear it here!"), bands need these new ways to get their music out there. Young people these days discover bands through Guitar Hero that they may not have otherwise. And they seek out the CDs and iTunes downloads.

Some feel that Led Zeppelin's line about "protecting the integrity of the master tapes" by refusing to allow games to use their songs is actually code for "Ante up, video game companies."

The money's there.
 
Piotr Rasputin said:
Games are a matter of taste. I enjoy the various Guitar Hero games, especially Metallica. They're not everyone's cup of tea, but they great party games because everyone enjoys music, and four at a time can play these games: Drums, Two guitars, singer. Have had a couple of great marathons playing the game with a group of friends.

There is a lot of money to be made for the bands. Check the list of individual bands' top iTunes downloads. More often than not, a song's appearance on a video game will put its downloads through the roof. Like when "Don't Stop Believin'" was on the Sopranos.

With CD sales way down, and radio an utter wasteland (classic rock stations' motto should be "If you have heard it a million times, you'll hear it here!"), bands need these new ways to get their music out there. Young people these days discover bands through Guitar Hero that they may not have otherwise. And they seek out the CDs and iTunes downloads.

Some feel that Led Zeppelin's line about "protecting the integrity of the master tapes" by refusing to allow games to use their songs is actually code for "Ante up, video game companies."

The money's there.

Led Zeppelin could make a great deal more money if they so desired. That may change in the future. Who knows, things change.

Some have posted on here in the past that Page is desperate for money and is in dire financial straights. I have yet to see any evidence of that.
 
Machine Head said:
Some have posted on here in the past that Page is desperate for money and is in dire financial straights. I have yet to see any evidence of that.

Had to be sarcasm, posted in the wake of the many re-releases of the catalog.

Page can't be hurting. He will be later because of selling his soul to the devil, of course.
 
Piotr Rasputin said:
Machine Head said:
Some have posted on here in the past that Page is desperate for money and is in dire financial straights. I have yet to see any evidence of that.

Had to be sarcasm, posted in the wake of the many re-releases of the catalog.

Page can't be hurting. He will be later because of selling his soul to the devil, of course.

It wasn't sarcasm, trust me.
 
buckweaver said:
If a friend has it, I'll play it, too. But it's one of those games I'd get bored with pretty quickly.

That's pretty much me too.

I did get one of the Guitar Hero games (the third one I think) when it was on sale at Best Buy. Think I paid less than $30.

Anyway, when I did play it, I did get bored with it after 3-4 songs. And there's no way in hell I can play it above the easiest level.
 
Hank_Scorpio said:
buckweaver said:
If a friend has it, I'll play it, too. But it's one of those games I'd get bored with pretty quickly.

That's pretty much me too.

I did get one of the Guitar Hero games (the third one I think) when it was on sale at Best Buy. Think I paid less than $30.

Anyway, when I did play it, I did get bored with it after 3-4 songs. And there's no way in hell I can play it above the easiest level.

I own a bunch of the Guitar Hero games. I went through a phase where I'd basically play them all summer. I mean, they ARE fun as hell.

I just haven't really had time to play much since my daughter was born last summer.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top