Joel, I appreciate your points.
This is obviously a very difficult situation that stirs many emotions.
I was among the folks on here so frustrated and angered that I quickly moved to curse the people at Dave's paper. My instincts from what I read on Dave's thread on getting fired and the experiences we all know too well in this industry still lead me to think that, yes, Dave was treated unfairly and this adds to the terrible shame of the tragedy.
I just don't want to add more pain to it.
As Joel said, I'd again offer caution in judgment and choice of words aimed at Dave's paper and former co-workers.
We really don't know everything and there may be people there hurting more than we really understand. For one thing, I know I was upset with someone who didn't reach out to me after I lost my job. Finally, only much later did he acknowledge how badly he felt and admitted he just didn't know what to say.
I'd hate to see him get skewered on here because I died before he had a chance to find the right words.
Again, I was one of the biggest offenders in judging without first-hand knowledge, so I'm putting myself in that category as well.
The bottom line is, if folks at that paper were callous and scheming, they know who they are and they have to live with this situation. You can only hope they learn from it.
If there is a more complicated story, they know that too. We all seem to feel this story, but we do have to remember no matter what we feel, we're trained enough as journalists to recognize our biases and lack of complete information.
Even if things went exactly as we seem to think, we all have treated someone poorly at different times in our lives -- we don't usually expect them to then die.
To any managers reading this, at the A-T or anywhere else, please try to learn from this horrible situation: Remember the human beings who are giving you their heart and soul. Remember how quickly you can ruin their lives. If nothing else, show them the compassion you may need yourself one day -- possibly this one as you think about a former colleague who died way too young.
To the folks working for those who never will heed this lesson: Remember to care more about yourself than the folks you work for, no matter how much passion you have for your job. Take care of yourself.
I love the idea of remembering Dave and his passion for this industry, and making sure the readers he served for so long have a shot at remembering him. In that way, I'm glad people got those comments out there to avoid Dave's story just being hidden or not told fully. I know the paper's seeming lack of desire to honor a longtime employee inspired the degree of passion.
But with all due respect to the good intentions and horrible emotions of the moment that took over many of us ... we don't know the full truth -- we only have a good amount of information that seems to add up, but wouldn't be strong enough to go with in print.
I'm again struck by one of the tributes on here talking about Dave editing the crap out of a story and kicking it back to make sure the reporter got the other side, tough as it may have been to do so.
That's what we do.
And when we don't have all the information, we don't just run wild with something. We choose our words carefully to offer as much responsibility as information.
As for the Dave Feltner Memorial Assistance Program, I think that is one damn good way to honor the man's memory. I was initially going to suggest a scholarship fund at one of the local schools, but when Lindsey mentioned the resource I thought it was a good idea to start some kind of Dave Feltner thing on here. I think jps' idea is excellent.