No autographs!

[Evil ... Thy name is Orville Redenbacher!!]

By MIKE FITZPATRICK, AP Baseball Writer



NEW YORK - No autographs allowed — in any language. When a Japanese reporter recently asked Roger Clemens for an autograph, he got a signed photo and a swift penalty: His membership in the Baseball Writers' Association of America was revoked.

Hiroki Homma of the Fuji Evening News said he didn't realize he was breaking the rules, though he took full responsibility and apologized to the New York Yankees.

"I didn't know," Homma said. "It was my fault."

Ballplayers coming from Japan to the majors need to make adjustments. So, too, do the many international journalists covering the big leagues — clubhouse etiquette is just one example of the many cultural changes they face.

When is the most appropriate time to approach players? How much of an obstacle is the language barrier? Why so many cross-country flights?

In Japan, reporters aren't allowed inside baseball locker rooms. They request postgame interviews through public relations officials, and players emerge from the clubhouse to answer questions while dressed in civilian clothes. In the offseason, players are occassionally paid for a special chat.

But sports writers and players often have a much friendlier relationship than in the United States.

Hiroshi Kanda of Kyodo News has covered the Yankees since Hideki Matsui arrived in 2003 and said players and writers occasionally go out for dinner together in Japan. They also hang out with each other on road trips — conjuring images of a long-ago era in the majors when cigar-smoking scribes rode the trains alongside the blue-collar ballplayers they chronicled, dealing cards and chatting away through the night.

That sort of relationship, much different than the strictly professional ones now customary in America, sometimes leads to Japanese reporters requesting autographs from players back home.

"It happens," Kanda said.

Signs posted in big league dugouts and clubhouses remind reporters they're not allowed to ask for autographs, and Major League Baseball's policy regarding media access includes an explicit explanation.

"There shall be no seeking of autographs, no touching or removing of equipment or personal items from lockers, and no sampling of players food spreads," the policy says. "Any member of the media who violates these regulations will lose his or her accreditation."

Kanda said some ballparks even have those rules posted in Japanese and Spanish, though not Yankee Stadium.

"It's been a long time since (Hideo) Nomo came here. Hundreds of Japanese reporters work in the States," Kanda said. "I think it's clear. I don't think it's a matter of the rule. It's a written rule. Sometimes the unwritten rule is hard to understand. But this is a written rule.

"I know the language barrier sometimes causes problems, but you can't make an excuse, because we are in the States," he added.

Homma, in his first season covering the Yankees, said he approached Clemens on July 5 with a stack of pictures of the pitcher taken by the newspaper's photographer. Homma said he presented the pictures to Clemens, figuring the seven-time Cy Young Award winner would enjoy having them to commemorate his 350th win.

Then, Homma asked the Rocket to sign one of the photos for him, which Clemens did.

A member of the Yankees' security staff noticed and mentioned it to Isao Hirooka, the club's Pacific Rim Media Advisor.

"It's really a shame that the reporter involved didn't know the rule," said Ikuro Beppu, editor of the Fuji Evening News, a tabloid newspaper based in Tokyo. "His act was purely resulting from his ignorance of the rules, and we accept his punishment."

Beppu said the newspaper sent letters of apology to the Yankees and the Major League Baseball Players Association.

The BBWAA, the organization that votes for the Hall of Fame and postseason awards, confiscated Homma's card. Homma can apply for membership again next year.

According to team policy, the Yankees revoked Homma's season credential, but will replace it with a pass on a game-by-game basis.

"In speaking to both Hiroki and representatives of the Fuji Evening News, I feel it was an innocent mistake," Yankees spokesman Jason Zillo said. "We've had an extremely positive relationship with the Japanese media throughout the years, and we continue to enjoy working with them."

"At this time I consider this issue resolved," he said.

 

[PhilaYank36]

****ing dumb-ass.

 

[Chi City 81]

Not the first time it's happened with a Japanese reporter. At the 2000 U.S. Women's Open, I was walking with a group of four or so reporters behind Michael Jordan, who just finished playing in a Pro-Am. A Japanese reporter tried to stop MJ and ask for his autograph. MJ's handler turned around (Jordan kept on walking) and said, "You know better than that."

The rest of us laughed.

 

[Write-brained]

No doubt you've got to learn the rules, but I actually feel bad for the guy.

 

[Johnny Dangerously]

Yes. It's easy to think like an American journalist would about this, but imagine going to Japan and trying to learn the language and a different set of rules, rules that go against what you're used to here.

 

[mike311gd]

And yet you never see a player kicked out of the league for asking for one of our autographs. ...

 

[Write-brained]

I didn't realize baseball policed that kind of stuff. I always figured that was rule journalists imposed on themselves. Do all sports do that?

 

[slappy4428]

Wonder if he would have kept his credential if it was Drew Henson instead of Roger Clemens :

 

[Write-brained]

Yes. It's easy to think like an American journalist would about this, but imagine going to Japan and trying to learn the language and a different set of rules, rules that go against what you're used to here.

Absolutely. But when you know you're going to a culture that is in some ways polar opposite of ours, one would think you would take special care to learn what's proper and improper so you don't risk instantly losing your credibility.

That being said, the only thing I know about Japanese baseball culture is what I saw in Mr. Baseball.

And I still feel bad for the guy.

 

[buckweaver]

Yes. It's easy to think like an American journalist would about this, but imagine going to Japan and trying to learn the language and a different set of rules, rules that go against what you're used to here.

Absolutely. But when you know you're going to a culture that is in some ways polar opposite of ours, one would think you would take special care to learn what's proper and improper so you don't risk instantly losing your credibility.

You know, that seems to be a very common American expectation: if you go to their home/country/whatever, it's your responsibility to adapt to their culture.

I can't help but wonder if other cultures don't hold the same expectation, because this seems to be a common misunderstanding between America and everybody else, whether it's Hispanic people moving north, Japanese reporters traveling east, etc.

Are we the only ones who hold this expectation?

 

[boots]

I'm sorry that he got his card confiscated but rules are rules in the BBWAA. It sounds like an honest mistake but I think there may be more to this story. My guess is that he may have been guilty of doing this sort of thing for a while, was asked to stop, and didn't.

 

[Write-brained]

Yes. It's easy to think like an American journalist would about this, but imagine going to Japan and trying to learn the language and a different set of rules, rules that go against what you're used to here.

Absolutely. But when you know you're going to a culture that is in some ways polar opposite of ours, one would think you would take special care to learn what's proper and improper so you don't risk instantly losing your credibility.

You know, that seems to be a very common American expectation: if you go to their home/country/whatever, it's your responsibility to adapt to their culture.

I can't help but wonder if other cultures don't hold the same expectation, because this seems to be a common misunderstanding between America and everybody else, whether it's Hispanic people moving north, Japanese reporters traveling east, etc.

Are we the only ones who hold this expectation?

I'm not sure. I understand why a lot of Hispanics don't worry about it here, especially the illegal ones.

If you're going to live here illegally I imagine you're not going to spend a lot of time talking with anybody outside your trusted network ...

 

[zeke12]

I'm sorry that he got his card confiscated but rules are rules in the BBWAA. It sounds like an honest mistake but I think there may be more to this story. My guess is that he may have been guilty of doing this sort of thing for a while, was asked to stop, and didn't.

This is pure conjecture, though, right?

You don't have any evidence of him asking for other autographs?

 

[crusoes]

Wonder if he would have kept his credential if it was Drew Henson instead of Roger Clemens :

Of course, there was an incident where a reporter asked for Henson's autograph, and Clemens was the enforcing official.

 

[joe_schmoe]

Perhaps we could learn something from this. The report says it's common practice in Japan for reporters and baseball stars to often dine together, so things like this are common practice. Here we keep it on a professional level...in some cases, like White-Brained has suggested, don't even take any type of handouts whatsoever for any services in some things.
What can we learn? Japan has the highest newspaper circulation rate per capita than any other nation, and is third in total circulation, ahead of the U.S. While US papers are making cutbacks, and seeing circulation drops, Japan papers have seen a slight climb.
Not sure what we can learn exactly, but maybe there is something to this let's-not-be-so-distant attitude the Japanese have. And yeah, yeah, yeah, I know it's a clubhouse/MLB type rule, but we'd still say it's unprofessional to have relations with players like that.

 

[Write-brained]

Perhaps we could learn something from this. The report says it's common practice in Japan for reporters and baseball stars to often dine together, so things like this are common practice. Here we keep it on a professional level...in some cases, like White-Brained has suggested, don't even take any type of handouts whatsoever for any services in some things.
What can we learn? Japan has the highest newspaper circulation rate per capita than any other nation, and is third in total circulation, ahead of the U.S. While US papers are making cutbacks, and seeing circulation drops, Japan papers have seen a slight climb.
Not sure what we can learn exactly, but maybe there is something to this let's-not-be-so-distant attitude the Japanese have. And yeah, yeah, yeah, I know it's a clubhouse/MLB type rule, but we'd still say it's unprofessional to have relations with players like that.

WRite-Brained. The R is not silent. Anyway, I'm not sure your conclusion is correct. Go to Europe and Japan and you'll see not only more people reading newspapers but an overall emphasis on education. They want to be informed. They are just as knowlegdable about stuff in our country and surrounding countries as they are in their own country.

We're suffering from the dumbing down of America. Half the high school seniors in my state don't graduate on time. We're a stupid country with stupid, self-centered people. Perhaps being more sociable would help ... but being professional isn't the reason people don't read the paper.

 

[joe_schmoe]

Ack, sorry Write-brained, honest mistake.

I don't disagree with anything you said there either.
Like I said in my post, Not sure what we can learn....I'm just throwing it out there. But back in Americas newspaper glory days, reporters were pretty tight with subjects then too. I don't know that we can ever go back, but I think we are going too far the other way where we all seem to cold and distant from each other, and athletes/celebrities, police officers, even some of the high school coaches I deal with hate talking to us. The only people that enjoy taking are fellow journalists (and even then there's the news vs. sports mentality) and parents who are more than happy to tell me how to do my job.

 

[forever_town]

Go to Europe and Japan and you'll see not only more people reading newspapers but an overall emphasis on education. They want to be informed. They are just as knowlegdable about stuff in our country and surrounding countries as they are in their own country.

Someone from a European country could very easily make a comparison between the size of their country and the size of a state in the United States. Or make that comparison in terms of population. Ask most Americans to make the reverse comparison and see what happens.

I also don't think American journalistic emphasis on professional distance does any good compared to the more familiar relationship between Japanese players and media. It's six in one hand, half a dozen in the other as far as I'm concerned. And I say that because each nation's culture is radically different.

 

[slappy4428]

Wonder if he would have kept his credential if it was Drew Henson instead of Roger Clemens :

Of course, there was an incident where a reporter asked for Henson's autograph, and Clemens was the enforcing official.

I did not know that....

 

[Trouser_Buddah]

Ack, sorry Write-brained, honest mistake.

It sounds like an honest mistake but I think there may be more to this story. My guess is that joe may have been guilty of doing this sort of thing for a while, was asked to stop, and didn't.