Chris Carpenter: Hall of Famer?

[3OctaveFart]

Lets hear your thoughts, members and moderators.
I really think this guy has a budding case.
Sure, he will need another 50 or 60 wins.
But he is already established as a money pitcher in the postseason.
And that has been justification for putting in Shilling.

 

[Gehrig]

http://www.sportsjournalists.com/forum/threads/86466/

D_B

 

[JC]

Lets hear your thoughts, members and moderators.
I really think this guy has a budding case.
Sure, he will need another 50 or 60 wins.
But he is already established as a money pitcher in the postseason.
And that has been justification for putting in Shilling.

He sured pitched well in this post season

 

[LongTimeListener]

Yeah 3OF is definitely Carlton.

 

[Azrael]

This is in baseball?

 

[3OctaveFart]

Don't be so rigid.
I predict he will win more than 200 games.
Shilling is only at 216.
Do not forget he has been injured a lot and has thrived in a terrible time for pitchers.
His postseason exploits are impressive.

 

[3OctaveFart]

Yeah 3OF is definitely Carlton.

I thought there were rules against this type of thing.
Funny how you can get away with it.
Stay on topic, fool.

 

[Stoney]

http://www.sportsjournalists.com/forum/threads/86466/

D_B

Except it's even stupider today than it was a year ago. And it was monumentally stupid then.

 

[Azrael]

A quick look at Baseball Reference 2012 puts him 17 innings closer to not entering the Hall of Fame.

 

[JC]

I just read that thread again, it appears IJAG is arguing with herself.

 

[Stoney]

I just read that thread again, it appears IJAG is arguing with herself.

Of course because Whitman went back and deleted all his posts in between IJAG's.

 

[KYSportsWriter]

Don't be so rigid.
I predict he will win more than 200 games.
Shilling is only at 216.
Do not forget he has been injured a lot and has thrived in a terrible time for pitchers.
His postseason exploits are impressive.

This is a terrible time for pitchers?

 

[JC]

I just read that thread again, it appears IJAG is arguing with herself.

Of course because Whitman went back and deleted all his posts in between IJAG's.

I know it just looked odd.

 

[Mizzougrad96]

I'm going to go see if he compares favorably to Koufax.

 

[LongTimeListener]

**** has been a hell of a lot calmer since then though -- different guy. This is just a dumb**** troll's attempt to start a flame war. Thread should be nuked.

 

[JC]

**** has been a hell of a lot calmer since then though -- different guy. This is just a dumb**** troll's attempt to start a flame war. Thread should be nuked.

Agreed.

 

[3OctaveFart]

Neither of you clowns have that power, fortunately.
If Moddy wants to nuke it, so be it.
Koufax only had six good seasons.

 

[Armchair_QB]

If there was a Douchebag Hall of Fame he'd be a first ballot guy.

 

[Azrael]

Koufax only had six good seasons.

And at least three great seasons. And four seasons as the best pitcher in baseball.

How many does Carpenter have?