S Stitch Active Member Joined May 28, 2007 Messages 8,970 May 15, 2012 #1 I know he just got called up, but if he put together 15 MVP-caliber seasons, should he be considered?
I know he just got called up, but if he put together 15 MVP-caliber seasons, should he be considered?
LongTimeListener Well-Known Member Joined Feb 25, 2009 Messages 40,531 May 15, 2012 #2 First steal was of home. So I say yes.
Azrael Well-Known Member Joined Feb 5, 2010 Messages 28,883 May 15, 2012 #3 Hit himself in the head, so no. Never.
cranberry Well-Known Member Joined Oct 31, 2002 Messages 19,286 May 15, 2012 #4 Bad haircut so definitely not until third ballot.
P Pancamo Active Member Joined Jul 7, 2006 Messages 3,855 May 15, 2012 #5 15 MVP-caliber seasons? Yes. 14 MVP-caliber season? He can buy a ticket like you and me.
zagoshe Well-Known Member Joined Sep 15, 2003 Messages 15,688 May 15, 2012 #6 Along with his friends in the media, he whines and cries when he gets hit by a pitch, so no way....
Moderator1 Well-Known Member Joined Oct 13, 2002 Messages 32,791 May 15, 2012 #7 We've been over this. Not funny. Don't start another one.