Albuquerque Journal beat writer reassigned for email

[Shaggy]

http://www.thewizofodds.com/the_wiz_of_odds/2010/10/new-mexico-beat-reporter-is-reassigned.html

Reporter writes an email to a player trying to get confirmation that he quit the team. The end of the email says "If you have quit, maybe that's a step in the right direction."

Gets reassigned when the email gets back to his editors.

I have an opinion on this, but I wanted to hear what others think.

 

[Batman]

Hard to say without reading the full e-mail. If the player quit the team to focus on academics, as the blog post said, the reporter could've meant it as a friendly word of encouragement based on past exchanges. Like he understood the player was in trouble academically, and the reporter meant it as "maybe that'll give you more time to study and help you get back on track academically."
Seems like there might be more to this than meets the eye.

 

[J Staley]

First, I should say that I know the reporter and used to work with him.

That disclosure out of the way, I didn't think what he did was bad. To me the part of the e-mail I read sounded empathetic. If the reporter had reason to think the player had quit, then that's probably not an easy time in the athlete's life. If the reporter is going to do his job and get the player to tell his side, he needs to be somebody the athlete can talk to.

To me, observing how Mike Locksley operates, it seems like he's hypersensitive to how the media portrays him. This is the same coach who accosted a student reporter at a sports bar because the he wrote that the program was in shambles.

Archuleta (the UNM beat writer) had covered the Lobos for more than a decade. I can't believe the paper wouldn't stand up for him more. And I don't like that the UNM athletics department went over his head.

I could see a coach in Locksley's awful, self-inflicted, I-killed-a-program situation reading more into the e-mail than what's there, but it seems like all these actions were taken without regard for Archuleta's side of things.

 

[Shaggy]

That's what i think, too. Archuleta was just trying to establish a connection so the player would open up.

I really don't think he meant anything bad by it, and it's unfortunate that the university and, I assume the player, took it that way.

Perhaps it could've been worded a little better but removing him from the beat is overreacting based on these facts.

 

[murphyc]

Without seeing the entire e-mail, I'd have the same line of thinking as Batman. Seems odd his paper would throw him under the bus so easily. Can't be an easy beat to cover when the football is so bad. Only person at UNM I could see being happy with the football team's struggles is Rick Alford.

 

[jlee]

I think the operative words is "maybe." Many people in the athletics department probably don't see how he tip-toed around accusing the player of being a quitter if he left the team and leaving the possibility open that the player hasn't left.

I'm just shocked that folks in the newsroom brass didn't either.

 

[Fran Curci]

It seems obvious to me that the writer was simply trying to provoke his subject into commenting. I would think there were other factors involved and this was the tipping point for management to react.

 

[Ace]

We work with words. Our job is to communicate.

If you are emailing a player you cover -- which I assume for most reporters would not be an everyday thing -- you need to make sure what you write isn't misconstrued. You also have to assume other people will see it.

That line obviously could be misconstrued. A reporter should know better.

I don't know if that's what I would have done if I were his boss, but I can understand why he was reassigned.

 

[nmmetsfan]

Gnat, meet elephant gun

 

[OnTheRiver]

According to the article linked, he's averaging a team-leading 29 yards per game.

I'm gonna let that sink in.

 

[Den1983]

According to the article linked, he's averaging a team-leading 29 yards per game.

I'm gonna let that sink in.

I saw that. [Anchorman] "I'm not even mad. That's amazing" [/Anchorman]

But it sickens me how newspaper management more often than not don't back their reporters or editors. Was it a mistake, yes. But enough to be reassigned? Hell no. Especially for a 30-year vet on the beat.

 

[WriteThinking]

But it sickens me how newspaper management more often than not don't back their reporters or editors. Was it a mistake, yes. But enough to be reassigned? Hell no.

I'll go along with that.

Maybe someone was looking for a reason to reassign him.

 

[BigRed]

Without seeing the entire e-mail, I'd have the same line of thinking as Batman. Seems odd his paper would throw him under the bus so easily. Can't be an easy beat to cover when the football is so bad. Only person at UNM I could see being happy with the football team's struggles is Rick Alford.

Who is Rick Alford?
Is he any relation to Steve Alford, the men's basketball coach who this Iowa grad enjoyed seeing fall on his face in the 2nd round of the NCAA Tournament last March?
Just curious.

 

[Mark2010]

Rick Alford is former Sports Editor at the Longview (Wash.) Daily News.

As for the reporter, no way he should lose his beat over that. Without having a tone of voice, I can read that email two totally different ways, the second being: "if you have quit the team, that's probably a good move for you. This winless bunch of plowhorses was a waste of your time and talents. Move onto something better."

 

[Luke_Knox]

I also know Greg and worked with him. Total professional, hard worker, great at what he does. Further disclosure: I'm a designer, not a reporter. So this is not my field of expertise as it is with some of you.

But I don't see a big problem with what he did, and certainly I'll echo others in questioning management for not standing up for him after the years he's put in on that beat.

Hang in there, Greg.

 

[TimmyP]

Who is Rick Alford?
Is he any relation to Steve Alford, the men's basketball coach who this Iowa grad enjoyed seeing fall on his face in the 2nd round of the NCAA Tournament last March?
Just curious.

If there's a record for the most career NCAA Tournament losses to double-digit seeds, then Alford has to be closing in on it, if he doesn't have it already. That always makes me smile when I think about that egotistical, hypocritical assclown.

 

[murphyc]

Without seeing the entire e-mail, I'd have the same line of thinking as Batman. Seems odd his paper would throw him under the bus so easily. Can't be an easy beat to cover when the football is so bad. Only person at UNM I could see being happy with the football team's struggles is Rick Alford.

Who is Rick Alford?
Is he any relation to Steve Alford, the men's basketball coach who this Iowa grad enjoyed seeing fall on his face in the 2nd round of the NCAA Tournament last March?
Just curious.

Oops, my bad. This former Iowa resident did mean Steve. I've done stories for Rick Alford before, good guy with a good reputation.

 

[Mystery Meat II]

Any chance there's more to this than "good reporter makes one mistake and gets unfairly punished for it"? I don't know the guy from Adam, and I only know what I read here, but are we sure that there isn't more to the story?

 

[nmsports]

In the "what goes around, comes around file"...UNM fb player in question was dismissed from the team this week for academic deficiencies.

 

[OnTheRiver]

In the "what goes around, comes around file"...UNM fb player in question was dismissed from the team this week for academic deficiencies.

There goes 2 first downs per game.