I want the USMNT to progress as much as anyone. In my lifetime as a soccer fan, they've made galactic strides. The team on the pitch tonight, pathetic though they played, is still massively better quality-wise than the teams of the 90s that broke through or even the 2002 quarterfinal team. (That, if we're being honest, got a pretty kind Round of 16 draw to get a familiar foe in Mexico.)
Admittedly, it has stagnated quite a bit since the 2010-14 Cup team era. We have about the same amount of European-based players as we did then playing at about the same level.
But I'm here to tell you ... this **** is hard. Progressing in the World Cup is not The Price Is Right yodeler game where you're guaranteed to just keep rising. Some nations have been on more or less the same plateau for their entire soccer-playing history and they drink, eat and sleep the game.
Some of the powerhouses have done not much better than we have. England hasn't been in a semifinal since 1990. Brazil has fallen short of winning the Cup each time since 2002. Italy has missed three straight Cups, unfathomable! Germany is in its worst-ever World Cup stretch since winning in 2014.
Spain and France, once thought of as under-achievers, finally realized their potential in the last quarter century.
And we're not the only ones trying to progress. African nations are finally maximizing their talent, Morocco being a legit threat to win the Cup, a first for an African nation. Japan continues to get better. The stable Middle Eastern countries continue to get better. If Iran could ever have any national stability, watch out. One or two of the medium-sized European nations will make their occasional glory run.
One day, China will get its **** together. So will Russia. We're not competing just against ourselves.
As Cosmo said, I don't want participation trophies either. Tonight's performance sucked and should be called out as such. We have come far enough not to be paternalistic about our results. When we suck, our players and coaches deserve the criticism for it.
But I'm also realistic about how and whether we progress. Nations playing soccer on a serious level 100 years before we did are still chasing the same dream we are after all.