New Wilco

[Dick Whitman]

Wondering what others think. I am loving it so far, probably more than any album since "A Ghost is Born" and possibly "Yankee Hotel Foxtrot." In fact, the first song - the way Tweedy's voice kind of just rises out of some background noise, reminds me a lot of "I Am Trying to Break Your Heart." It feels like they really put a lot of work into it. I've only listened a couple times so far in the car, so I'll probably really start to differentiate between the tracks as the week goes on, but it's already an album I keep coming back to because it just sounds so interesting.

 

[John]

I keep trying with Wilco, and I want to really like the band, but the connection just isn't there.

Meanwhile, I like Uncle Tupelo, Son Volt and Farrar's solo stuff more than ever.

Odd.

 

[westcoastvol]

Reminds me a lot of YFT more than any other record.

I like the edgy/more experimental stuff better than the *****whip tunes.

 

[JayFarrar]

Wilco has drifted so far from its alt-country (whatever that is) roots that if you liked them for that sound, they aren't that band anymore.

Tweedy has shrugged off the "American Radiohead" comparisons and called it lazy writing, but musically, each album has been different up until the last couple albums, much like the British Radiohead. On the flipside Wilco, besides Tweedy and John Stirratt, has been different for each album.

They've only recently found a groove in terms of consistent membership and this album, which I like, quite a bit, is a mix of previous album sounds but not a completely different direction.

So it isn't really that odd. Farrar, Son Volt, Uncle Tupelo all still sound like the Wilco you once listened to.

 

[YGBFKM]

Tweedy and Wilco have creatively lapped Farrar and Son Volt about 46 times to this point. Farrar peaked with Trace.

Having said that, I don't like The Whole Love. It just sounds dull to me. And I keep hearing the YHF comparisons. Guess that makes sense since that album is my least favorite.

 

[Cosmo]

Just to repeat my post from the music thread:

Anyway, after a few listens: The new Wilco is musically 100 times better than Wilco (The Album) was. It's like they finally realized they had Nels Cline in the band and let him loose, especially on Art of Almost, which is just a ****in' banger. Tweedy is a little all over the place with his songwriting, but this album feels like a bit of a mix of A Ghost is Born and Sky Blue Sky. AGIB is still my favorite Wilco record, though its gets a run from time to time from Summerteeth. So I really like the influences. Pretty complex musically. Pitchfork gives The Whole Love a 6.9, but the review is actually pretty glowing.

 

[joe]

Usually I like every song on a Wilco album, even if it takes a few plays to get into the rhythm of it. However, I only like about half of Sky Blue Sky (Side With the Seeds my favorite). Wilco (the Album) was a first for me: one I couldn't listen to. I tried, but, plainly, it sucked from beginning to end.

I'm hopeful that the new album is a return to form. I don't expect another At Least That's What You Said, but I also don't expect another (name the song) on The Album.

 

[SheffieldAvenue]

Wilco has always seemed, to me, like a band that everyone says they like to sound cool at parties, but no one actually likes. Definitely couldn't tell you any of their music.

 

[YGBFKM]

Cool story, bro.

I really liked Wilco the Album. Top three for me along with Being There and a Ghost is Born.

 

[Brian]

Wilco has always seemed, to me, like a band that everyone says they like to sound cool at parties, but no one actually likes. Definitely couldn't tell you any of their music.

I call this the "Argument Your Dad Makes Because He's Lost Touch With Contemporary Culture" Argument. Right up there with "That Commercial Made No Sense But At Least They've Got You Talking About Their Product" argument everyone's uncle pulls out each Super Bowl Sunday.

i like the new album. It just takes me months for albums to click for me, so I hesitate to judge them. I once hated The National's second album for 8 months before suddenly loving it. My musical tastes are on roller skates.

 

[Cosmo]

I listened to Art of Almost and At Least That's What You Said back to back today. Art of Almost certainly holds its own. Might be one of my top five Wilco songs. It's that good.

 

[PCLoadLetter]

It's definitely growing on me.

And "One Sunday Morning" is already on my short list of my favorite Wilco songs.

 

[I Should Coco]

It's definitely growing on me.

And "One Sunday Morning" is already on my short list of my favorite Wilco songs.

That makes two of us, PC.

And as I posted on the music thread, anyone who's enjoyed Wilco albums over the past 15 years will find something they like on The Whole Love.

I'm hoping they will have some western U.S. tour dates in 2012.

 

[SalukiNC]

Been getting a little bored about halfway through it.

 

[YGBFKM]

It's definitely growing on me.

And "One Sunday Morning" is already on my short list of my favorite Wilco songs.

That makes two of us, PC.

And as I posted on the music thread, anyone who's enjoyed Wilco albums over the past 15 years will find something they like on The Whole Love.

I'm hoping they will have some western U.S. tour dates in 2012.

I will not give in to the peer pressure. You can't make me like it.

 

[I Should Coco]

That's OK. We'll always have DBT ... and the White Sox.

 

[YGBFKM]

Going to see the Warren Haynes Band next weekend. Ever seen him without the Mule?

 

[PCLoadLetter]

This may be old, but I saw it tonight for the first time.

Jeff Tweedy covers the Black Eyed Peas.

http://tinyurl.com/3eelpvv

 

[Care Bear]

This may be old, but I saw it tonight for the first time.

Jeff Tweedy covers the Black Eyed Peas.

http://tinyurl.com/3eelpvv

That made my night. Thank you.

 

[YGBFKM]

Ya, that was hilarious. I will give the new album another spin just for that awesome evisceration.

And watching Tweedy there made me realize just how different the personalities of he and Farrar are. It's no wonder their partnership was doomed and they no longer speak.