Interesting question for the board

[Googlaw]

So I have two positions open on my staff — a writer and a designer. I had interest from an in-house copy editors in news. She is by far the most qualified candidate. Here's the snag: the editor says 'No.' Said the candidate can't switch sides because it would create too much of a headache on the news side.

My question is this: Can he do that?

This person is miserable in news and wants to either join our sports staff or leave the business. So if she's unhappy, and wants to try something new, why can't she?

 

[HejiraHenry]

My question is this: Can he do that?

Of course.

So if she's unhappy, and wants to try something new, why can't she?

Because they said so.

 

[Ben_Hecht]

Hope she puts "them" to the test.

Be curious to hear.

 

[Write-brained]

Goo, which editor are you talking about? EE (executive editor?) or news editor. If it's the news editor go over his head.

 

[slappy4428]

hell yeah go over his head...
Is there a hangup with changing jobs -- ie: she's been in this position three months and is not allowed by company policy to change until working in it for six months?
If she wants it bad enough, she can play the "gender discrimination" card. Might not apply in this case without knowing the particulars, but it can turn many management types into jello if played right.

 

[EE94]

That's just an editor who doesn't want to have to go through the hassle of replacing the person you will be taking.
I've been on both sides of that argument, but ultimately, a good organization would let a talented person move to a place where he/she can perform to their best.

 

[fishwrapper]

Are you saying your newsroom is political?

 

[Meat Loaf]

This person is miserable in news and wants to either join our sports staff or leave the business. So if she's unhappy, and wants to try something new, why can't she?

Because two unfilled jobs saves more money than just one.

 

[Songbird]

So I have two positions open on my staff — a writer and a designer. I had interest from an in-house copy editors in news. She is by far the most qualified candidate. Here's the snag: the editor says 'No.' Said the candidate can't switch sides because it would create too much of a headache on the news side.

My question is this: Can he do that?

This person is miserable in news and wants to either join our sports staff or leave the business. So if she's unhappy, and wants to try something new, why can't she?

That's what I'm doing. I don't want to cover sports anymore, at least in this capacity as a one-man show, so the publisher said he'll move me elsewhere in the company in the next month or so to design and do other things. Some employers are more helpful than others in this kind of situation.

 

[Bob Slydell]

What they said. Hey, if the editor says no, there really isn't a whole lot you can do about it. Just keep talking to the editor about it, and have the girl plead her case.

Otherwise, I suggest going over his head to the publisher. That always works well.

 

[Lucas Wiseman]

Happened to me at one stop... I was in news, wanted to go to sports... there was an opening in sports, news editor wouldn't let me go... at about the same time I had been talking to another place about a job... got an offer... walked in, told them if I couldn't go to sports I was leaving. I think they thought I was bluffing. I wasn't.

 

[Eagleboy]

Happened to me at one stop... I was in news, wanted to go to sports... there was an opening in sports, news editor wouldn't let me go... at about the same time I had been talking to another place about a job... got an offer... walked in, told them if I couldn't go to sports I was leaving. I think they thought I was bluffing. I wasn't.

That's what I was going to suggest. If this employee can't switch sides and the only other alternative is leaving, tell her to let them know that if she doesn't take the position, she's out of there. In any case, the editor might realize that her position will be vacant no matter what he chooses and she'll, hopefully, be allowed to move.

 

[chazp]

Happened to me at one stop... I was in news, wanted to go to sports... there was an opening in sports, news editor wouldn't let me go... at about the same time I had been talking to another place about a job... got an offer... walked in, told them if I couldn't go to sports I was leaving. I think they thought I was bluffing. I wasn't.

That's what I was going to suggest. If this employee can't switch sides and the only other alternative is leaving, tell her to let them know that if she doesn't take the position, she's out of there. In any case, the editor might realize that her position will be vacant no matter what he chooses and she'll, hopefully, be allowed to move.

That only works if she's willing to walk if they tell her no.

 

[Big Buckin' agate_monkey]

Happened to me at one stop... I was in news, wanted to go to sports... there was an opening in sports, news editor wouldn't let me go... at about the same time I had been talking to another place about a job... got an offer... walked in, told them if I couldn't go to sports I was leaving. I think they thought I was bluffing. I wasn't.

Feel good to follow thru, or did you really want to stay?

 

[SixToe]

Happened to me at one stop... I was in news, wanted to go to sports... there was an opening in sports, news editor wouldn't let me go... at about the same time I had been talking to another place about a job... got an offer... walked in, told them if I couldn't go to sports I was leaving. I think they thought I was bluffing. I wasn't.

Awesome. Very nicely played.