Filing FOI for a coach's phone records: Good journalism or invasion of privacy?

[Omar_dont_scare]

So Arkansas is all a-quiver about this story where a fan filed an FOI for Houston Nutt's cell phone records, then forwarded his findings onto the board of trustees.

Juicy stuff abounds within. Good, meaty tabloid-type fodder.

Apparently, Arkansas paid the phone bill, thus the records were accessible. Now all those bills are going to a foundation loosely affiliated with the university, but as a "private" organization, not accessible under an FOI.

A few questions

1) If a university could do this with coaches' phone records, what would prevent a government from doing the same with phones owned by employees?

2) How many people in other places are going to follow suit?

3) Is this OK for a journalist? I mean, if you're investigating a particular story, that's one thing. But just to file an FOI them for the sake of doing so to see what dirt you can expose... I don't know, it seems like an unnecessary invasion of privacy.

Thoughts?

 

[Moland Spring]

Re: Subpoenaing a coach's phone records: Good journalism or invasion of privacy?

I know of a few football beat reporters (Joe Person of the State comes to mind) who do this all the time. Great journalism. If a coach is breaking the rules, making too many calls or whatever, the public needs to know. Wouldn't Kelvin Sampson's infraction have been uncovered earlier if an Oklahoman reporter had done this?

 

[Omar_dont_scare]

Re: Subpoenaing a coach's phone records: Good journalism or invasion of privacy?

I know of a few football beat reporters (Joe Person of the State comes to mind) who do this all the time. Great journalism. If a coach is breaking the rules, making too many calls or whatever, the public needs to know. Wouldn't Kelvin Sampson's infraction have been uncovered earlier if an Oklahoman reporter had done this?

That part I get, but what about the stuff in the Nutt transcript with all the wee-hour calls and texts to the female TV reporter? Is that news?

 

[SixToe]

Re: Subpoenaing a coach's phone records: Good journalism or invasion of privacy?

Given the high profile of coaches today and the possible, or probable, use of a state-owned telephone paid with university money, then yes.

 

[Inky_Wretch]

For people wondering what Omar is talking about...

http://deadspin.com/sports/college-football/ever-wonder-who-houston-nutt-talks-to-todays-your-lucky-day-249866.php

Seems like something a gossip columnist would be interested in, not something for the sports pages.

 

[leo1]

some schools, like florida, have a foundation set up exclusively for the purpose of making this kind of info non-public. from what i've been told, the foundation more or less pays the bills for the athletic department, so other than the basics of the football and basketball coach's contracts, most of the data is un FOI-able.

 

[Moland Spring]

Re: Filing FOI for a coach's phone records: Good journalism or invasion of priva

Yes, Leo is right. I think Ole Miss does this, as well. Sneaky bastards. I don't think the football coach having an affair is news. But the fact that he used a cell phone paid for by the public (pretty much) makes it news. Our tax dollars at work! And then, you go, well, what else has he used public money for....?

 

[Rockbottom]

Moland, next time you are in The Heart Of Dixie -- Alabama -- you might want to ask if Mike Dubose's affair was "news".

Just sayin'. :)

rb

 

[JayFarrar]

You can also get credit card statements, if a university card is used.
You can also FOI university-issued reimbursement checks if a personal card was used for university business.
All it means is that the black helicopter internet crowd is about to make the job very much harder for media outlets.
Everything will be moved to the various foundations and nothing will be available under FOI. Until someone mounts an expensive legal challenge to the foundation system, and that won't be happening anytime soon.

 

[scribbler]

I know of a few football beat reporters (Joe Person of the State comes to mind) who do this all the time. Great journalism. If a coach is breaking the rules, making too many calls or whatever, the public needs to know. Wouldn't Kelvin Sampson's infraction have been uncovered earlier if an Oklahoman reporter had done this?

Well, an Oklahoman reporter did do that.

 

[Mighty_Wingman]

All it means is that the black helicopter internet crowd is about to make the job very much harder for media outlets.
Everything will be moved to the various foundations and nothing will be available under FOI. Until someone mounts an expensive legal challenge to the foundation system, and that won't be happening anytime soon.

Yep. It's the Internets' fault. Damn Internets.

 

[mcwritermm]

Re: Filing FOI for a coach's phone records: Good journalism or invasion of priva

Coaches are accountable to NCAA compliance officers for all calls made involving recruiting, regardless of whether the phone bills are subject to the FoI Act. Most ADs have moved to paying a stipend to coaches, and coaches obtaining and managing their own mobile phones.

Very few D-1 athletic departments operate with taxpayers' (i.e., state or federal) revenue support.

 

[MU_was_not_so_hard]

Dumb question, but is this foundation thing the way Penn State gets away w/ not giving up Paterno's contract info?