1. Welcome to SportsJournalists.com, a friendly forum for discussing all things sports and journalism.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register for a free account to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Access to private conversations with other members.
    • Fewer ads.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

NFL Congressional hearings

Discussion in 'Sports and News' started by swamp trash, Mar 23, 2012.

  1. swamp trash

    swamp trash Guest

    This was originally posted on another thread but probably deserves its own given the potential fallout from a Congressional hearing if Goodell and/or league officials are brought to testify:

    In the interest of hopefully enlightening the subject a little more, here's something I blatantly stole from another message board:

    A Congressional investigation of NFL bounty programs and player safety could prove interesting and more than a tad uncomfortable for Roger Goodell, whose most notable biographical detail before becoming NFL commissioner was that he is the son of a former United States senator.

    Some suggested questions:

    1. After the 2012 NFC championship game, regarding a hit on San Francisco player Kyle Williams, New York Giant Jacquian Williams said, "We knew he had four concussions, so that was our biggest thing, to take him outta the game." And New York Giant Devin Thomas said, "He's had a lot of concussions. We gotta put a hit on the guy." Is the targeting of players with a history of injuries to put those players out of the game against NFL rules? If so, did the league investigate the actions of the New York Giants regarding Kyle Williams?

    2. Do you believe such targeting of players with a history of injuries to put those players out of the game is commonplace in your league? If not, on what evidence do you base your belief? If so, does that mean that your game is too violent?

    3. Since the imposing of sanctions against the New Orleans, news reports quoting former players have appeared in numerous media outlets, including the Washington Post and the Buffalo News, stating that Gregg Williams ran identical bounty programs with other teams including the Washington Redskins, the Buffalo Bills and the Tennessee Titans. Indeed, there appears credible and substantial evidence that before the 2006 Monday Night game between Washington and Minnesota, there was a $15,000 bounty offered to prevent Minnesota quarterback Brad Johnson from finishing the game, and Washington defensive line coach Greg Blanche stated that player fines would be "taken care of."

    Do you find such stories disturbing? Do you believe such stories warrant serious investigation? If after serious investigation, credible evidence shows that in all probabllity those incidents occurred, do you believe that sanctions should be imposed against those football organizations and coaches involved if they are still working in the NFL?

    4. What steps did your league take to investigate the stories of bounty programs at Washington, Buffalo, Baltimore and Tennessee? Could you please tell us which persons with the league conducted and were directly responsible for those investigations so that we can subpoena them to testify and what reports of those investigations exist so that we can subpoena those reports?

    5. Do you believe those investigations were a whitewash? If not, did your league find that other teams were offering bounty programs to put players out of a game? If not, should we not conclude that your league did not look hard for evidence of bounty programs with other teams?

    6. If our investigation shows that bounty programs such as the program you found in place under Gregg Williams in New Orleans has been commonplace for decades and part of the culture of your game, and if your league's investigations have been unable to find even one other team with a bounty program--despite numerous media reports with names and quotations attesting to such programs--would you not agree that Congress would be warranted in taking serious action to ensure that these programs finally come to an end and player safety strengthened?

    7. Before the 2012 New Orleans Saints and San Francisco 49er playoff game, a former NFL player and radio commenator Bill Romanowski on San Francisco station 95.7 said, "This has got to be a stretcher game. I'm talking...bring out the stretcher and take Colston to the hospital. Take Darren Sproles to the hospital because he got knocked out." And of course, in that game on the opening drive, Saints running back Pierre Thomas was knocked out of the game because of a helmet to helmet hit. The irony of the comments being directed at the one team against which you imposed sanctions is striking. However, my question is: Do you think that the culture of your game is such that most defensive and special team players talk the way Romanowski talked?

    8. What importance does the league place on player safety? Given the importance you place on player safety, how can the league propose an 18 game season? If credible medical and other scientific studies exist showing that an 18 game season will adversely affect player health and safety, will you commit to us that you will cease campaigning for an 18 game season?

    9. Regarding the recent investigation of the New Orleans Saints, did game video reveal that the offer of money resulted in any illegal tackles or hits by Saints players? Can you tell us how many and which ones?

    10. Much has been made of the hits taken by Brett Farve in the NFC championship game between New Orleans and Minnesota. In that game, do you believe that Farve received illegal hits that were motivated by payment of a bounty? If so, and if I tell you that your league in its football highlight videos has made money playing up those hits--and we have the video if tyou would like to see it--do you believe the league was wrong in doing so?

    And with just a bit more time combing the Internet, we could come up with 40 more. Perhaps Goodell thought that he had to act. But by hitting the Saints hard--and focusing so much on player safety rather than the integrity of league investigations--he may have opened Pandora's box.
  2. PeterGibbons

    PeterGibbons Member

    Here we go again, the guys who haven't been able to pass a budget for the last three years are going to fix sports yet again. The economy is in the tank and some douchebag senator pandering for votes calls for congressional hearings where he has no business being.

  3. State legislatures should be considering questions of tort law, not the federal government.
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page