1. Welcome to SportsJournalists.com, a friendly forum for discussing all things sports and journalism.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register for a free account to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Access to private conversations with other members.
    • Fewer ads.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Letter in Dec. 22's SI

Discussion in 'Journalism topics only' started by hwkcrz1, Dec 18, 2008.

  1. hwkcrz1

    hwkcrz1 Member

    Read this letter in the Dec. 22 edition of Sports Illustrated. I've never really seen a letter like this in Sports Illustrated.

    Future of Hunting
    "I was disappointed that Matthew Teague's story on hunting (A More Dangerous Game, Nov. 24), which discussed the death of my son Kenton, contained information that was simply not true. Teague described a phone call between mother and son and included supposed quotes from that conversation without first verifying their accuracy with me. He tarnished a treasured memory of the last conversation I shared with my son."
    Lori Carnegie, Oshawa, Ont.
     
  2. broadway joe

    broadway joe Guest

    Wow. I remember that story. The woman's son was killed by wolves. I assume the writer was a freelancer. I also assume he'll never write for SI again, if he really made stuff up. I'd really like to know more of the details here.
     
  3. jps

    jps Active Member

    that was the kid killed by the wolves, yes? thought it was a great story - disappointed to see in the letter it wasn't entirely accurate. no editor's note on the letter, though?
     
  4. jps

    jps Active Member

    http://vault.sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1148866/index.htm
     
  5. Jake_Taylor

    Jake_Taylor Well-Known Member

    I enjoyed that story too. Doesn't a big mag like SI have fact checkers that call and verify things like that?
     
  6. SockPuppet

    SockPuppet Active Member

    Back in the day, yes.
     
  7. somewriter

    somewriter Member

    Seems pretty irresponsible to just run the letter without comment from the editor. I'd no more believe one person than the other, but SI should at least comment on whether the comment is justified. If it's not, it obviously shouldn't have run the letter in the first place.
     
  8. daemon

    daemon Member

    What hurts worse - getting eaten by wolves or getting thrown under a swiftly moving bus by your editors?

    It's a shame, because the quote in question is an extremely negligible part of the story. You could have removed it from the piece and it would not have been affected in the slightest.

    I'm guessing what happened, from the way the story read, is that the writer spoke with the father, who relayed his version of the conversation between the mother and son, and the writer simply took it as gospel.

    Seems like a fairly innocent mistake, although it's a good reminder to think long and hard before you put something in quotations that you didn't hear for yourself, regardless of how it affects your "narrative."

    On a sidenote. . .

    I enjoyed the story, but after thinking it through, the whole premise -- that this young man died because people don't hunt enough -- to be something of a quantum leap. Although I very much enjoyed the final two sentences.
     
  9. shotglass

    shotglass Guest

    I find it awfully difficult to piece together why a writer would do that -- if he did.
     
  10. crusoes

    crusoes Active Member

    You're kidding, right?
     
  11. playthrough

    playthrough Moderator Staff Member

    Getting eaten by wolves wouldn't hurt for long. Editing, or lack thereof, or your own screwup, can hurt for years.
     
  12. hankschu

    hankschu Member

    Sorry. Can't agree with those who said it was a good story.

    The basic premise of the story: We should be able to kill animals anywhere we humans want, lest we be killed, and restrictions on hunting are wrong.

    This incident did not occur in downtown Chicago. It was in an outpost in the middle of the frozen north. The animal did what it was supposed to do.
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page