Cy Young Awards thread

I'd go:

N.L.
1) Dickey
2) Kershaw
3) Cueto

A.L.
1) Verlander
2) Price
3) Hernandez

 

Dickey

Gonzalez

Weaver

 

I'd entertain arguments about Kimrbel, Rodney, or Chapman, but it felt like a year with enough good starters that no relievers need apply.

 

1. Gio
2. Dickey
3. Anyone else.

 

How do you justify Gonzalez ahead of Dickey?

 

You know the answer to that.

 

1) Gonzalez
2) Strasburg
3) Walter Johnson

 

Verlander and Dickey.

 

1. I'm a Nats fan. DURRRRR.

2. Dickey's a nice story. Heartwarming, really. But Gio is pitching in a pennant race. Lots more at stake. More pressure.

I don't expect Gio to win, though. People love Dickey's story. And he's got a cool pitch, too!

 

Until a reliever pitches 200 innings, that's every year for me.

 

I couldn't care less about R.A. Dickey's story. I would vote for him because he's been a workhorse, leading the NL in strikeouts, innings and complete games, while posting a 2.69 ERA that's second-best in the NL by one hundredth of a point.

1. Dickey
2. Clayton Kershaw
3. Johnny Cueto

1. Justin Verlander
2. David Price
3. Jered Weaver