2017 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot

No Raines. No Schilling. No I-Rod.

Shocker.

 

*shrugging shoulders*

Schilling would be 7th on that list.

 

You don't think Rodriguez is a hall of famer?

 

I think he's in the conversation. But no, not necessarily. And I'm totally going with gut feeling.

 

You can vote for 10.

 

And I would not. I would seldom, if ever, vote for 10. Not missing your point; I'm saying I would vote for those six and those six only.

 

The catcher who won an MVP and gunned down base runners daily during his career doesn't pass the "eye test," I guess.

 

Then you're baseball stupid. How is Curt Schilling not a Hall of Famer? How is Tim Raines not a Hall of Famer? How in the name of all that is holy and good is Ivan Rodriguez not a Hall of Famer?

 

You don't say.

 

Dang. Shot down again.

Hey, there would be something for his plaque. "He was a catcher. And he was an MVP once."

 

Is this one of those fun times when you post on a thread, say something numb-skullish, and then defend it by saying that you don't have to defend it?