Injuries and McNabb and Vick

[Almost_Famous]

Much is made of Vick's inability to stay healthy because he runs so much ... and also because he hasn't won a title yet.

McNabb also hasn't won a title, he likes to run, but by season's end, he'll have missed more games than Vick.

Statistically, McNabb was having a great year. But if you're a GM, would you rather have McNabb or Vick?

Neither has won a title, though McNabb has been to a Super Bowl. McNabb is 2-0 (i think) against Vick in the playoffs (though both wins WERE in Philly).

It's tough to compare teams - PHilly has always had a beastly defense while Atlanta ... yeah, you can look up how bad they have been.

 

[Chuck~Taylor]

Donovan McNabb [sarcasm off]

 

[pallister]

Tom Brady.

 

[XXXX]

are you a forkING MORON? vick over mcnabb? vick couldn't carry mcnabb's jock. also mcnabb wouldn't want him to cause ron mexico has herpes.
that is all i will say as there is another thread discussing mcnabbs injury.

 

[DyePack]

The games were in Philly because Vick can't get homefield advantage for his team because he's mediocre.

 

[BYH]

Ahh yes. Vick has lost three straight games so A_F is now pashive aggressively stoking the fires by saying vick is good because, well, he's healthy.

Well goddamn I guess you must think Brett Favre is the greatest player ever.

Ladies and gentlemen, give a big Atlanta welcome to your 2007 starting quarterback MATT SCHAUB!!!!

 

[Chi City 81]

Ahh yes. Vick has lost three straight games so A_F is now pashive aggressively stoking the fires by saying vick is good because, well, he's healthy.

Well goddamn I guess you must think Brett Favre is the greatest player ever.

Ladies and gentlemen, give a big Atlanta welcome to your 2007 starting quarterback MATT SCHAUB!!!!

Favre ain't healthy any more.

 

[buckweaver]

Ahh yes. Vick has lost three straight games so A_F is now pashive aggressively stoking the fires by saying vick is good because, well, he's healthy.

Well goddamn I guess you must think Brett Favre is the greatest player ever.

Ladies and gentlemen, give a big Atlanta welcome to your 2007 starting quarterback MATT SCHAUB!!!!

Favre ain't healthy any more.

He just better be healthy on Dec. 10. I didn't spend $$$ for nosebleeds at Candlestick to see Jeff Tedford's Next Flameout.

 

[fmrsped]

For that matter, A_F, would you rather have Vick, McNabb, or Aaron Brooks?

I mean, when healthy, Brooks gives his team a chance to win, just as much as Vick. The Falcons lost by two touchdowns today, but the Raiders only lost by four.

If I'm a GM starting a team, I'd much rather have Brooks, if I'm choosing between mediocre black quarterbacks on irrelevant teams.

 

[shotglass]

I'm no Vick fan. But on the other hand, I often wonder where and how Donovan McNabb was annointed as one of the greats, too.

If his career were over tomorrow, my lasting image of him would be a pash at his receiver's feet.

 

[pallister]

You'll never work at ESPN now, Shottie.

 

[Beef03]

Brett Favre. We'd be undefeated for sure.