Recent content by Andy Messerupsmith

I’m not sure what Plate Appearances have to do with one’s worthiness for HOF, but your point belies one of the worst arguments. Just because voters may have made poor decisions in the past we should continue making bad decisions?

And the 5 slots on the Modern Ballot were for people who were already voted down by the writers. The Modern Ballot and the other two are a slap in the BBWAA’s face. Cronyism at its best.

The operative term being “old head” and not the newbies who think everyone deserves to be in the Hall of Pretty Good Players. How anyone could fill up 10 spots is amazing.

Murray Chass