Freddy Got Fingered, Jimmy got pinched ...

... 14 years later ... For not returning a VHS tape. I mean, he rented that movie, he's been punished enough

Man arrested for not returning 'Freddy Got Fingered' VHS rental in 2002

 

I remember when I was in high school, I rented a couple of Nintendo games from a local video shop. My older brother was leaving the house one day, so I asked him to drop them off on his way.

He forgot, and proceeded to go out of town for 2 weeks for work (he was working as a merchant marine). I started getting calls about returning the games, and insisted I'd brought them back. I eventually realized I'd given them to my brother.

When my brother got back in town and returned the games, I talked my younger brother into going with me to the store. I had him run in, toss them on the counter and run back out. We sped away.

I never went back in that store again. Later, I found out it was owned by the father of the state attorney general. We joked for years afterward every time we'd drive by there that they had an APB out for us.