Eli Manning out at least a month? All year? Not at all? Depends who you believe

Re: Eli Manning out at least a month? All year? Not at all? Depends who you beli

Manning suffered a sprained shoulder.

http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/football/giants/2007/09/11/2007-09-11_manning_has_sprain_jacobs_umenyiora_more.html

 

Or perhaps you Atlanta Falcons fans will have Charlie Frye next week. Another rumor circulating that it's Frye for Redman.

 

No, the Browns are currently trying to trade him, rumors are the Giants and ATL are the targets, if he's not traded they'll cut him.

 

When there are conflicting reports on an injury, it's best to assume the team is either lying or at least bending the truth.

That aside, I guess Chuck needs a new quarterback to overrate. One game and he is ready to declare Manning better than Roethlisberger and Rivers combined? That's almost as bad as his hyperbolic love of Michael Vick. Both have done a good bit more to prove themselves as NFL quarterbacks than Manning so far and one big game doesn't change that.

Only one of those three quarterbacks has won a playoff game and that is Roethlisberger. He has won five of them, including a Super Bowl. Ok, he sucked in the Super Bowl and in the first-round playoff victory over the Jets the previous year. But he was also the team's best offensive player in the three AFC playoff victories in 2005 (look it up. I've posted those numbers enough on here).

Manning has a ways to go to catch up to him or to Rivers, much less surpass them.

But one thing is clear from any perspective....Charlie Frye sucks.

 

Anderson will probably start, Dorsey #2, Quinn remains third QB (at least that's how it should be).

 

No, he meant Frye. FOR THE GIANTS. "your" starting QB talking to Giants fans.

 

Manning WILL start Sunday for the Giants.
He might not finish but I bet he starts.

 

Giants fans are off the hook, Frye goes to Seattle:

http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/7214446