Another Top 25 voter (USC beat writer) ...

Of course, when you consider the AP Top 25 has nothing to do with the BCS .....

 

Right, but why should this bullshit system determine which team's loss is more significant than another...

It's a real shame because a Division I-A college football playoff would make the NCAA Tournament and the Super Bowl seem insignificant by comparison...

 

How do we know who the best is? Seriously, who won't know until that last game.

I'll give this guy credit for being consistent -- he's got USC out of the top 10 and has Arkansas at No. 15, which makes sense given the game between the two. I like Boise State at No. 13 but wonder why he's got Rutgers down at No. 21. And Notre Dame is overrated, go figure.

Point is, it's all subjective. You just have to let the season play itself out and go from there.

 

I just can't believe people are voting for Oregon State. I know they just beat USC, but seriously they are 5-3 on the season.

 

I can't believe he voted Oregon No. 17. They got their doors blown off by Washington State.

 

The guy voting from the Oregonian doesn't even have Oregon in the top 25, though I believe the Ducks still deserve to be in it. I just think if you are going to put a fourth PAC-10 team into the top 25 it should be Washington State not Oregon State, but I am a homer.

 

WSU won at Corvallis. Something USC couldn't do.

 

As long as Wisky ain't playin' for the title, life's fantastic.

 

Don't be a playa hatah.

 

Well, I did like Bevell at QB. Dayne, too.

 

I was more of a Bollinger and Calhoun guy. But Jimmy Leonhard might be my all-time favorite college athlete.

 

Do you mean "those other teams ... have knocked off" a team ?

Ranked victories
Ohio St -- Texas
Michigan -- ND, Wisconsin
Texas -- Oklahoma
Auburn -- Florida
Florida -- Tennessee, LSU
Tennessee -- Cal
USC -- Arkansas, Washington St
ND -- Ga. Tech

WVU could potentially defeat 5 Louisville on the road and 15 Rutgers in the final game. You beat two ranked teams (I mean teams that finished ranked), that's about standard operating procedure, it seems ...