American Idol 4/24

When doc found out that Jordin sang Liverpool's song, he immediately went to our DVR. Now he's trying to find a good version of them all singing it on youtube. Fanboy looser.

 

Dead. To. Me.

 

I didn't think Jordin was good at all last night. She had a ton of the nervous vibrato/shakiness on notes going on, and the pitch wasn't always exactly there. I love that song, but really don't like it as a pop song either.

Still, she has become the chosen one because of the full package, which is as important as anything on this show.

 

I just think it's funny that Taylor Hicks appears to be all but forgotten, while Daughtry, Katharine McPhee, Snaggletooth and Kellie Pickler have all released pretty successful albums...

Even Bucky Covington got a good review recently in EW...

 

OK, that's a good argument. Like I said, I never watched before this year. I guess I just showed my ignorance.

 

Ha, it's not ignorance. I just took you to say you didn't watch last year, not you hadn't watched at all before. No biggie.

Underwood and Clarkson are the shining Idols.

 

So far, they're 2 for 5 with the winners...

 

I heard Bucky Covington's song the other day. For country, it's really not bad. I mean, I thought he couldn't sing worth shit on the show, but I heard the song and thought "this is pretty good" then they announced it was him and I was shocked.

 

Buh... buh.. buh.. fantasia's the shit

 

Seacrest just promised "the most shocking result" in history :-\

 

Any bets on what this "most shocking results ever" is?

Two people with tied votes? Melinda getting knocked off?