AL Cy Young .. whaddya think?

Re: AL Cy Young .. whaddya think?

Can't believe anyone is seriously arguing K-Rod for anything. It's one of his worst seasons ever -- except, of course, for that one stat. Yes, Soria is having a better year, as is Papelbon, which makes K-Rod the fifth-best closer in the AL strictly this year. ... Anyway, Lee should win it unanimously. Case closed, hands down, all that jazz.

 

mussina. end. of. fucking. discussion.

also book the man his own wing in the hall, too.

 

damn. solid.

 

Also take into consideration that Lee's done what he's done on a team with no closer, a gas-can bullpen and a putrid offense. Truly amazing season.

The only question I have about Lee is what's the more impressive number so far, 22 or 2?

I say it's 2.

 

Absolutely. He oughta win the thing unanimously.

 

Lee should win unanimously, but where does Lester (15-5, 3.15) fit in. Top 5? 10?

 

I'd say top 25, easily.

 

TSP, love ya man, but your defensiveness makes you look foolish. Your guy's the winner. No one's doubting it, far as I can tell.

Lee's season has been unbelievable, especially in the midst of the Indians' tank job.

 

Considering that you only vote for top three for Cy Young, I'd say nowhere.

 

Agreed. It's Lee, Halladay and someone else, but you know Dice-K and Lester will split some votes.

 

That would be right then, I thought it was five for some reason.

10 for MVP?

 

10 for MVP is correct, why I'll never know.