True, given those parameters, I'd have to go with the Mays catch. This was a great one, but I don't know about best period though.
It was an incredible catch and one that we will see for many years to come (especially if the Mets win), but not the greatest. The Edmonds catch...
I couldn't agree more. I saw that Reese catch and at the time thought it was the much better catch, but it wasn't done by a member of an NY team.
This one at least saved two runs from scoring..the Jeter catch was a foul ball.
That catch will go on the same highlight reel with the Jeter catch where he caught the ball 2 feet from the stands and crashed into it...We'll see...
Separate names with a comma.